
CBAM penalties under Article 26 of Regulation (EU) 2023/956, as amended by Regulation (EU) 2025/2083, apply at €100 per tonne CO₂e, increased by inflation indexation, for every certificate an authorized declarant fails to surrender, and at three to five times that amount (€300–500 before indexation) for a person other than an authorized declarant who brings in CBAM-covered goods without complying.
Two penalty tiers govern non-compliance across all six covered sectors: iron and steel, cement, aluminium, fertilizers, electricity, and hydrogen. Understanding which tier applies to your situation determines the financial exposure you face and the corrective steps you must take.
The EU carbon border adjustment mechanism entered its definitive phase on January 1, 2026, making these penalties active and enforceable today.
What Are the CBAM Penalties?
CBAM penalties are financial sanctions charged for each CBAM certificate that should have been surrendered and was not. They are not flat fines assessed per shipment or per declaration. Each missing certificate, which stands for one tonne CO₂e, carries the penalty, so a larger shortfall produces proportionally larger exposure.
Article 26 of Regulation (EU) 2023/956, as amended by the Omnibus regulation Regulation (EU) 2025/2083, establishes the current penalty structure. Two violations trigger two distinct penalty levels.
Tier 1: The €100/tCO₂e Penalty for Authorized Declarants
Authorized declarants who fail to surrender, by September 30, the number of certificates that corresponds to the emissions embedded in the goods they imported in the preceding calendar year are liable for a penalty for each certificate not surrendered (Article 26(1)).
Article 26(1) states no euro amount of its own. It makes the penalty identical to the EU ETS excess emissions penalty in Article 16(3) of Directive 2003/87/EC, which is €100 per tonne CO₂e, increased under Article 16(4) of that Directive in line with the European index of consumer prices.
The amount charged is therefore above €100 once indexation is applied, at the level applicable in the year of importation of the goods.
Under Article 26(4a), the National Competent Authority (NCA) calculates the number of certificates that should have been surrendered from the net mass of the goods and default values, taking the free allocation adjustment into account.
Where the shortfall results from incorrect information supplied by an operator, a verifier or the independent person certifying carbon price documentation, the NCA may reduce the penalty (Article 26(1a)).
One critical feature of the Tier 1 penalty applies regardless of whether payment is made: paying the penalty does not cancel the certificate surrender obligation (Article 26(3)). The authorized declarant must still procure and surrender the missing certificates.
The total cost of non-compliance is therefore the penalty plus the CBAM certificate price, which for goods imported in 2026 is the official price of the quarter of import: €82.32/tCO₂e for Q3 2026, published October 5, 2026. At that price the combined exposure is at least €182.32 per certificate short, before indexation of the penalty.
Tier 2: The €300–500/tCO₂e Penalty for Unauthorized Importers
Any person other than an authorized CBAM declarant who brings CBAM goods into the EU without complying with the Regulation faces a penalty of three to five times the Tier 1 amount for each certificate not surrendered, which is €300–500 before indexation (Article 26(2)).
Article 26(2a) applies the same penalty to importers without authorization that exceed the 50-tonne threshold, counting all emissions embedded in the goods they imported in that calendar year. In that case, payment of the penalty releases the importer from the obligation to submit a declaration and surrender certificates for those imports.
The multiplier between three and five is set by the relevant NCA according to the duration, gravity, scope, intentional nature and repetition of the non-compliance and the person's level of cooperation.
The NCA may reduce the penalty where the importer exceeded the threshold by no more than 10% of that threshold, or in the cases referred to in Article 17(7a), though not below the Tier 1 level.
The Commission's news item of January 14, 2026 reported more than 12,000 applications submitted by January 7, 2026 and more than 4,100 operators authorized.
The March 31, 2026 deadline for provisional importing has since passed, and the backlog has not fully cleared: DEHSt's authorization guidance (updated June 9, 2026) still advises applicants that numerous submissions remain unapproved, chiefly due to incomplete applications or missing evidence, and recommends checking the CBAM Register regularly for outstanding document requests.
Importers that applied by March 31, 2026 may continue importing provisionally until the competent authority decides (Article 17(7a)). An importer above the 50-tonne threshold with no application on file by that date has no such cover.
Customs rules reinforce this penalty regime. Under Article 25(1), customs authorities do not allow the importation of CBAM goods by any person other than an authorized CBAM declarant, without prejudice to the de minimis exemption in Article 2a.
An importer that relies on the exemption and then exceeds the threshold is identified afterwards through the monitoring set out in Article 25a.
CBAM Penalty Summary Table
The 3 violation types and the applicable penalties are listed below.
| Violation | Who It Applies To | Penalty Rate | Regulation Article |
|---|---|---|---|
| Failure to surrender sufficient certificates by September 30 | Authorized CBAM declarants | €100 per certificate not surrendered, increased by inflation indexation | Article 26(1), as amended by 2025/2083 |
| Bringing in goods without complying, or exceeding the 50-tonne threshold without authorization | Persons other than authorized CBAM declarants | Three to five times the Article 26(1) penalty (€300–500 before indexation) per certificate not surrendered | Article 26(2) and (2a), as amended by 2025/2083 |
| Non-reporting during transitional period (historical, 2023–2025) | All importers during transitional phase | €10–50 per tonne of unreported emissions | Article 35(5) of Regulation (EU) 2023/956; Article 16 of IR (EU) 2023/1773 |
Note: The transitional period penalty (2023–2025) applied to failure to submit quarterly reports, not to certificate surrenders. Certificate obligations only began with the definitive phase on January 1, 2026. A quarterly holding shortfall, possible from 2027, carries no per-tonne penalty: Article 22(3) gives the declarant one month from the NCA's notification to top up.
How CBAM Penalty Enforcement Works
CBAM penalties are enforced by the 27 National Competent Authorities (NCAs), one designated by each EU member state. NCAs receive their mandate under Regulation (EU) 2023/956 and carry direct responsibility for authorization, inspection, and penalty issuance within their jurisdiction.
An authorized declarant registered in Germany is subject to enforcement by Deutsche Emissionshandelsstelle (DEHSt); one registered in the Netherlands falls under the Nederlandse Emissieautoriteit (NEa).
The enforcement process follows a structured sequence. After the annual CBAM declaration deadline of September 30 each year (first deadline: September 30, 2027 for calendar year 2026 imports), the NCA reviews submitted declarations and compares surrendered certificates against verified embedded emissions.
Where a shortfall is identified, the NCA issues a formal penalty notice. The declarant then faces a dual obligation: pay the penalty assessment and acquire the remaining certificates.
How NCAs Detect Non-Compliance
NCAs have three primary detection mechanisms for identifying CBAM non-compliance.
The first is declaration review. Each authorized declarant submits a CBAM declaration through the CBAM Registry by September 30. The system automatically compares certificates surrendered against embedded emissions declared. Any gap triggers a shortfall flag for NCA review.
The second is customs data integration. Article 25 of Regulation (EU) 2023/956 requires customs authorities to automatically transmit import data to the CBAM Registry for each shipment of Annex I goods, including EORI number, CN code, quantity, and country of origin.
The Registry cross-references this data against the declarant's account. Shipments recorded in customs but absent from CBAM declarations are flagged automatically.
The third is review under Article 19. The Commission and the NCA may review a CBAM declaration within the period ending with the fourth year after the year in which it should have been submitted, including by audit at the declarant's premises (Article 19(2)).
Under Article 15, the Commission also carries out risk-based controls on the data and transactions recorded in the CBAM Registry and informs the NCAs concerned of any irregularities.
Does Paying the CBAM Fine Cancel the Certificate Obligation?
Paying the Tier 1 penalty does not release an authorized declarant from the certificate surrender obligation (Article 26(3)). Both apply simultaneously and independently. The penalty addresses the regulatory infraction. The certificate surrender addresses the underlying carbon cost that CBAM is designed to equalize with the EU ETS. These are separate legal obligations under Article 26 and Article 22 respectively.
The mathematical consequence is straightforward. An authorized declarant who is short by 1,000 certificates at the September 30 deadline owes a penalty of at least €100,000 before indexation (1,000 × €100) and must still purchase and surrender the 1,000 certificates. At the official Q3 2026 certificate price of €82.32, that adds €82,320. Total exposure: at least €182,320 for a 1,000-certificate shortfall.
This deliberate design mirrors the EU ETS excess emissions penalty structure, where ETS installations also face both the financial penalty and the obligation to surrender the missing allowances. The additive logic does not carry over to an importer penalized under Article 26(2a): there, payment of the penalty releases the importer from the declaration and surrender obligations for those imports.
How to Avoid CBAM Penalties as an Authorized Declarant
Authorized declarants can manage penalty exposure through 4 proactive compliance steps carried out before the annual declaration deadline.
The 4 steps for avoiding the Tier 1 authorized declarant penalty are listed below.
-
Track the quarterly holding requirement. From 2027, authorized declarants must hold, at the end of each quarter, CBAM certificates corresponding to at least 50% of the embedded emissions in goods imported since the start of the calendar year. The quantity is determined on default values without the mark-up or on the certificates surrendered for the preceding year, with the free allocation adjustment taken into account (Article 22(2)). A quarterly shortfall carries no per-tonne penalty: the NCA notifies the declarant, who has one month to top up (Article 22(3)). A serious or repeated infringement is a ground for revoking authorization (Article 17(8)), and persistent under-holding signals a likely shortfall on September 30.
-
Obtain verified actual emissions data early. Using default values from Implementing Regulation (EU) 2025/2621 avoids verification costs but carries mark-ups of 10% in 2026, rising to 20% in 2027 and 30% from 2028. Actual verified emissions from production installations are typically lower than defaults for efficient producers. Accurate data prevents both over-purchasing and under-surrendering.
-
Engage an accredited verifier before the capacity crunch. Verifier registration in the CBAM Registry opened on September 1, 2026. As of November 12, 2026, seven verification bodies are documented as accredited by five national accreditation bodies (ESYD in Greece, Accredia in Italy, Swedac in Sweden, RvA in the Netherlands and BELAC in Belgium). The Commission's official list of accredited verifiers is still unpublished. The first declaration deadline is September 30, 2027, leaving a compressed window for physical site visits to non-EU production installations. Market estimates put verifier fees at €5,000 to €50,000 per installation. Lining up verification arrangements now reduces the risk of declaration delays caused by verifier unavailability.
-
Submit the CBAM declaration and surrender by September 30. The Tier 1 penalty attaches to certificates not surrendered by that date. Where no declaration is submitted, the NCA determines the number of certificates that should have been surrendered and requests their surrender within one month (Article 19(5)). The declaration, the certificate surrender, and the record-keeping period (until the end of the 4th year after the year in which the declaration was or should have been submitted, Article 7(6)) all operate together. A CBAM declaration filed on time with accurate data is the core protection against the Tier 1 penalty.
The CBAM declaration process outlines the full data requirements and submission steps for meeting the annual deadline.
What you must have on file before the declaration deadline, with the provision behind each item. Instant download.
We store only your email address for these alerts. Privacy policy
Contextual Border: Who Faces the Higher CBAM Penalty Tier?
The higher penalty tier, three to five times the Tier 1 amount, applies to persons other than authorized CBAM declarants who bring in CBAM goods without complying with the Regulation. Three categories of importer face this elevated penalty exposure.
Importers Who Missed the March 31, 2026 Authorization Deadline
The authorization application deadline for provisional importing during the definitive phase was March 31, 2026, under Article 17(7a) inserted by Regulation (EU) 2025/2083. Importers who applied by that date may continue importing provisionally while their application is processed, with the NCA having up to 120 days to reach a decision.
Importers who did not apply by that date and continued importing above the 50-tonne threshold without authorization face the Tier 2 penalty on all emissions embedded in that year's imports (Article 26(2a)).
Where an application filed in time is refused, the NCA establishes the emissions embedded in goods imported between January 1, 2026 and its decision by reference to default values, and those emissions are used to calculate the penalty.
EU Importers Without an EORI Number or Direct Customs Registration
Where an importer is not established in a Member State, the indirect customs representative must obtain authorized CBAM declarant status (Article 5(2)).
The representative is then subject to the importer's obligations for the goods it brings in on that importer's behalf (Article 5(2a)). If this arrangement is not in place, no authorized declarant stands behind the imports, and they are treated as made without authorization.
Importers Whose Authorization Was Revoked
Authorization is refused where an Article 17(2) criterion is not met, for example where a decision found serious or repeated infringements of customs, tax, market abuse or CBAM rules in the three years before the application, or a serious criminal offence relating to economic activity was recorded in the five years before it (Article 9(1) of IR (EU) 2025/486).
It is revoked where the criteria are no longer met or after a serious or repeated infringement of the surrender obligation or of the quarterly holding obligation (Article 17(8)). An importer whose authorization is revoked and who continues importing after revocation faces the Tier 2 penalty.
Can CBAM Penalties Be Appealed?
CBAM penalties can be appealed through national administrative and judicial processes in the member state that issued the penalty. There is no dedicated EU-level CBAM appeals tribunal. The appeals route runs through the national court system of the member state where the NCA that issued the penalty is located.
For most importers, the first step is an administrative appeal filed with the NCA itself, requesting reconsideration of the penalty assessment. If the NCA upholds the penalty, the declarant may escalate to the national administrative court system.
Constitutional or interpretative questions about how Regulation (EU) 2023/956 applies in a specific case can ultimately be referred to the Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU), though this route applies to legal interpretation of the regulation, not to factual disputes about specific penalty calculations.
Enforcement is organised nationally, and the authorities differ in kind. On the Commission's list of national competent authorities (version of June 26, 2026), Germany's is the emissions trading authority DEHSt, the Netherlands' is the emissions authority NEa, Finland's is the customs authority Tulli, and Romania's is a directorate of the Ministry of Finance.
Article 26 fixes the penalty amounts for all of them; how each authority organises its reviews is a national matter.
Supplementary Questions on CBAM Non-Compliance
What Is the CBAM Fine for a Fraudulent Emissions Declaration?
Regulation (EU) 2023/956 sets no separate fine for a fraudulent emissions declaration. Where a review under Article 19 shows that too few certificates were surrendered, the Article 26(1) penalty applies to each missing certificate, and the missing certificates must still be surrendered. A serious or repeated infringement is also a ground for revoking authorization (Article 17(8)), after which any further imports fall under the Tier 2 penalty. Fraudulent declarations may also result in referral to national authorities for criminal proceedings under applicable member state law.
Does the De Minimis Threshold Eliminate Penalty Exposure?
Yes, as long as the importer stays within it. The 50-tonne annual mass de minimis threshold under Article 2a of Regulation (EU) 2023/956 as amended exempts importers whose total net mass of CBAM goods across all CN codes does not exceed 50 tonnes in a calendar year. They face no certificate obligation and therefore no penalty exposure, but must declare the exemption in the customs declaration. An importer that exceeds the threshold without authorization faces the Tier 2 penalty on all emissions embedded in that year's imports (Article 26(2a)). Electricity and hydrogen have no de minimis threshold and carry full CBAM obligations at any volume.
The CBAM de minimis threshold sets out how to calculate annual totals across product types and sectors.
Is the CBAM Penalty the Same Across All Member States?
The penalty level is harmonized EU-wide by Article 26 of Regulation (EU) 2023/956: the EU ETS excess emissions penalty of €100 per tonne CO₂e, increased by inflation indexation, for authorized declarants, and three to five times that amount (€300–500 before indexation) for persons other than authorized declarants. The multiplier between three and five is set by the NCA of the relevant member state, introducing limited national discretion in Tier 2 cases. Penalty collection, enforcement timing, and inspection frequency remain national matters, which is why enforcement culture differs across the bloc.
Are CBAM Penalties Tax-Deductible?
Whether CBAM penalty payments are tax-deductible depends on the tax law of the importer's member state of establishment. Most EU member states do not allow deduction of administrative penalties as business expenses, consistent with the principle that penalties must retain their deterrent effect. Importers should seek advice from their tax advisors in the relevant member state on the specific deductibility treatment of CBAM penalty payments.
Is CBAM Non-Compliance a Criminal Offense?
CBAM non-compliance under the certificate surrender and authorization framework is primarily an administrative regulatory offense, enforced through financial penalties by NCAs. Fraudulent or deliberately falsified emissions declarations may cross into criminal territory under member state law, particularly where the fraud involves customs law violations or tax evasion. The authorized CBAM declarant status and its related obligations are enforced administratively in the first instance, with criminal referral reserved for serious intentional violations.
Does the CBAM Penalty Apply to Historical Imports Before January 1, 2026?
The certificate surrender obligation and the associated Article 26 penalties (€100, and €300–500 for persons other than authorized declarants, in each case before indexation) apply only to imports made on or after January 1, 2026 (the start of the definitive phase). The transitional period (October 1, 2023 to December 31, 2025) carried a separate reporting obligation, with a different penalty of €10–50 per tonne of unreported emissions. That regime is governed by Article 35(5) of Regulation (EU) 2023/956 and Article 16 of Implementing Regulation (EU) 2023/1773 and is now historical. The CBAM regulation provides the full legislative timeline from entry into force through the current definitive phase rules.