CBAM Article 9 Deduction: Step-by-Step for EU Importers

Article 9 lets EU importers deduct qualifying foreign carbon prices from CBAM certificate obligations.

Page contents
An importer's Article 9 claim file holding proof of the carbon price effectively paid, its independent certification and the records kept, feeding a CBAM declaration; the conversion rules are still pending.

The CBAM Article 9 deduction reduces the number of CBAM certificates an authorized declarant must surrender, directly cutting the financial obligation when a non-EU producer has effectively paid a carbon price at origin.

Under Article 9 of Regulation (EU) 2023/956, EU importers can subtract a proportional certificate amount for every euro of carbon price effectively paid by the supplier at origin.

This guide covers the 5-step process for claiming the deduction, the status of the main exporting countries, and the open questions that compliance officers need to track before the first declaration deadline of September 30, 2027.


What Is the CBAM Article 9 Deduction?

The Article 9 deduction is a certificate reduction mechanism that allows an authorized declarant to lower the number of CBAM certificates surrendered at the annual declaration deadline, in proportion to any legally binding carbon price already paid by the producer in their country of origin.

The deduction targets double charging: if a non-EU steel producer pays €30 per tonne of CO₂ under their national emissions trading system, the EU importer of that steel does not bear the full EU ETS-equivalent cost on those same tonnes.

Three conditions come from Article 9 itself. The reduction is claimed where embedded emissions are determined on actual emissions (Article 9(1)); where default values are used, it may be claimed only by reference to yearly default carbon prices, which the Commission may set from 2027 (Article 9(4)).

The price must be "effectively paid", so any rebate or other form of compensation is taken into account, and voluntary offsets are not a carbon price. The documentation must be certified by a person independent from the declarant and from the third-country authorities (Article 9(2)).

How a foreign scheme's price is converted into certificates is left to an implementing regulation. The Commission published a draft on May 13, 2026, with the public consultation closing June 10, 2026.

A member-state vote was reported for September 2026, but as of October 12, 2026 no adoption has been confirmed: the Commission's CBAM legislation page lists no adopted act. The four recognition pathways and the 10% cap on Article 6 Paris Agreement credits therefore remain provisional draft rules, and no country's carbon price has been recognized.

The deduction does not reduce the price of individual CBAM certificates. The certificate price is the quarterly average of EU ETS auction closing prices for 2026 imports (Article 21(1a)) and the weekly average for goods imported from 2027 (Article 21(1)). What changes is the count of certificates surrendered.


How to Claim the Article 9 Deduction: 5 Steps for Authorized Declarants

The 5 steps below form the full workflow for an authorized declarant claiming an Article 9 deduction in the CBAM declaration filed via the CBAM Registry.

Step 1: Confirm the Origin Country Has a Qualifying Carbon Pricing Scheme

A reduction depends on a carbon price that is effectively paid and can be taken into account under the Article 9 rules, not on the existence of a scheme alone. As of October 12, 2026, no country's carbon price has been recognized. The table below shows where key exporting countries stand.

Country Carbon Pricing Scheme Article 9 Status (October 12, 2026)
South Korea K-ETS (Korea Emissions Trading Scheme), Phase 4 from 2026 to 2030 Not recognized; ICAP reports 100% free allocation for leakage-exposed sectors, steel among them
Switzerland Swiss ETS (linked to EU ETS) Goods of Swiss origin are outside CBAM under Annex III, point 1
United Kingdom UK ETS Not recognized (separate system from EU ETS)
South Africa Carbon tax, R308 per tonne CO₂e from January 1, 2026 Not recognized; allowances can reduce the tax base by up to 95%
China National ETS (extended to steel, cement, and aluminium smelting under the March 20, 2025 work plan) Not recognized; allowances are 100% freely allocated on an intensity basis
India Carbon Credit Trading Scheme (CCTS), starting up Not recognized
Turkey ETS Regulation of August 27, 2026; pilot for 2026 to 2027 Not recognized; 100% free allocation, so no carbon price is effectively paid
Russia Sakhalin regional pilot ETS only (ICAP); no national carbon price Not recognized
Brazil No operative ETS No carbon price to deduct

South Korea's K-ETS is the scheme most frequently cited by importers planning deduction claims. K-ETS Phase 4 runs from 2026 to 2030, and ICAP reports that sectors at risk of carbon leakage, steel among them, continue to receive 100% free allocation, so the price effectively paid can be far below the market price.

The Commission's May 13, 2026 draft implementing regulation sets out four recognition pathways (emissions trading systems, point-source carbon taxes, fuel-based carbon taxes, and mixed-compliance systems). As of October 12, 2026 the regulation has not been adopted, and the K-ETS has not been recognized ahead of the September 30, 2027 declaration deadline.

China and Türkiye are the two largest origins of EU imports of CBAM-covered goods (Annex I codes) by value: EUR 17.09 billion and EUR 10.83 billion in 2025 (Eurostat, Comext DS-045409, extracted October 12, 2026). Neither generates a deduction today.

China's national ETS was extended to steel, cement, and aluminium smelting under the work plan of March 20, 2025, but allowances are 100% freely allocated on an intensity basis, the scheme is not recognized, and it trades far below the EU ETS price.

Turkey published its ETS Regulation on August 27, 2026; the 2026 to 2027 pilot allocates 100% of allowances for free, so no carbon price is effectively paid, and the EU Customs Union relationship grants no Article 9 exemption.

Step 2: Obtain Verified Proof of Effective Carbon Price Payment

The Article 9 deduction requires documentation that the carbon price was "effectively paid" at the production installation level, not merely that a national scheme exists. This is operationally the most demanding element of the deduction claim.

The documentation set an authorized declarant must obtain from the non-EU producer includes 4 items. First, the compliance certificate or payment receipt from the national carbon pricing authority confirming the price paid per tonne CO₂e. Second, the verified emissions quantity for the specific goods exported to the EU importer.

Third, the calculation of the net price after subtracting any free allocations, export rebates, or state compensation received by the installation.

Fourth, certification of that documentation by a person independent from the declarant and from the third-country authorities, as Article 9(2) requires; under the draft rules this is an accredited "independent person", a role distinct from the CBAM verifier.

Voluntary carbon offsets and internal corporate carbon prices are excluded: Article 3(29) defines a carbon price as a tax, levy, fee or emission allowances under a greenhouse gas emissions trading system. An installation that purchased voluntary offset credits but is not subject to a mandatory government scheme cannot generate a deduction for the EU importer.

Step 3: Calculate the Deduction Amount

The Article 9 deduction formula produces the number of certificates to subtract from the total surrender obligation. The calculation uses 3 variables, and the conversion method itself is set by the implementing regulation under Article 9(5), which is still a draft.

The deduction formula is:

Certificates deducted = (Foreign carbon price in €/tCO₂) × (Specific embedded emissions in tCO₂) / (CBAM certificate price in €)

The arithmetic can be shown without assuming any country's price. A carbon price effectively paid of €20 per tonne of CO₂e, a hypothetical figure, converts at the official Q3 2026 certificate price of €82.32 into 20 / 82.32 = 0.243 certificates for each tonne of CO₂e on which it was paid.

The reduction sits inside the main formula: certificates = max[0; embedded emissions minus the free allocation adjustment minus the carbon price term] × mass.

What the reduction is set against can be anchored to a real case. South Korean hot-rolled coil (CN 7208) on default values carries a default of 2.118 tCO₂e per tonne, 2.3298 with the 2026 mark-up.

After the free allocation adjustment of 97.5% × the 1.370 benchmark, 0.99405 certificates per tonne remain: 4,970.25 certificates and €409,150.98 for 5,000 tonnes at €82.32.

On default values no reduction can be claimed until the Commission sets a default carbon price for the country (Article 9(4)); on verified actual values the reduction is limited to the price effectively paid.

The foreign carbon price must be converted to EUR. Article 9(5) of Regulation (EU) 2023/956 provides for conversion at the yearly average exchange rate.

Under the draft implementing regulation, still a draft as of October 12, 2026, the Commission publishes yearly average rates based on European Central Bank rates, or Eurostat data where no ECB rate exists.

Step 4: Include the Deduction in the Annual CBAM Declaration

The annual CBAM declaration filed via the CBAM Registry by September 30 of each year must include the Article 9 deduction claim as a distinct declaration element under Article 6 of Regulation (EU) 2023/956.

The declaration must state the carbon price effectively paid per country of origin and per goods type, supported by the documentation package assembled in Step 2.

The competent authority of the member state where the authorized declarant is established reviews the deduction claim. Reviews under Article 19 can request all supporting documents.

Authorized declarants must keep Article 9 documentation until the end of the fourth year after the year in which the declaration was or should have been submitted (Article 9(3)), the same period as the general record-keeping obligation.

Step 5: Monitor Commission Recognition Updates

The Commission published a draft implementing regulation on May 13, 2026 that sets out the recognition process and provides for "default carbon prices" that declarants may use for recognized countries where precise effective-price data is unavailable, alongside the option to use the actual price paid.

The draft covers how third-country ETS prices, carbon taxes, rebates, and compensation convert into CBAM liability reductions.

The public consultation closed June 10, 2026, and as of October 12, 2026 the regulation has not been adopted, so publication of recognized schemes and default prices remains pending ahead of the first declaration deadline.

The member-state comitology vote was reported for September 2026, per Carbon Pulse reporting citing a Commission official, but no vote outcome or adoption has been confirmed, as covered in the September 2026 vote news update.

Authorized declarants sourcing from countries with a carbon price, including South Korea, should monitor the Commission's DG TAXUD publications and the CBAM Registry notification system. A carbon price that cannot be taken into account under the adopted rules at the time of declaration filing generates no deduction.

The draft's four recognition pathways, its 10% cap on Article 6 credits, and its certificate-reduction formulas are set out in full in the carbon price deduction guide.


CBAM declaration checklist

What you must have on file before the declaration deadline, with the provision behind each item. Instant download.

We store only your email address for these alerts. Privacy policy

Does the Article 9 Deduction Apply to Your Imports?

The Article 9 deduction applies only to the fraction of embedded emissions on which a carbon price was effectively paid. For mixed supply chains, the deduction applies only to the goods and installations where that is the case.

An authorized declarant importing both South Korean and Turkish steel in the same calendar year would calculate any deduction separately by country of origin and production installation.

As of October 12, 2026 neither generates one: no scheme is recognized, Turkey's pilot ETS allocates every allowance for free, and Korean steel mills receive 100% free allocation according to ICAP.

The deduction is also bounded by the CBAM certificate obligation itself. The deduction cannot exceed the total certificate surrender requirement. If the foreign carbon price equals or exceeds the EU ETS-equivalent price, the net obligation approaches zero, and no negative certificate balance (refund) arises.


Article 9 Deduction: Contextual Border: How It Fits the Full CBAM Compliance Workflow

The Article 9 deduction sits within Step 9, the annual declaration, of the full 11-step CBAM compliance process for CBAM compliance for importers.

Understanding where the deduction fits in the overall compliance timeline prevents two common errors: failing to collect deduction documentation at the time of import, and claiming a deduction before Commission recognition of the scheme is confirmed.

The broader EU carbon border adjustment mechanism establishes the certificate system within which Article 9 operates. Certificates, their pricing mechanics, and the surrender obligation are defined by Regulation (EU) 2023/956 as amended by Regulation (EU) 2025/2083. The Article 9 deduction is a reduction mechanism within that system, not a separate payment track.

Does South Korea's K-ETS Qualify for the Article 9 Deduction?

Not as of October 12, 2026: no country's carbon price has been recognized under Article 9, and the K-ETS is no exception. K-ETS is a government-mandated, legally binding scheme under the Greenhouse Gas Emissions Trading Scheme Act that covered 77.75% of South Korea's national greenhouse gas emissions in 2023, according to ICAP. Phase 4 runs from 2026 to 2030, and ICAP reports that sectors at risk of carbon leakage, steel among them, continue to receive 100% free allocation, so the price effectively paid can be far below the market price.

The Commission's draft implementing regulation on Article 9, published May 13, 2026 and open for consultation until June 10, 2026, remained unadopted as of October 12, 2026; a member-state vote was reported for September 2026 but no adoption has been confirmed. EU importers sourcing CBAM South Korea goods should collect K-ETS payment documentation now so that a deduction can be claimed if the rules allow it.

Can China's ETS Generate an Article 9 Deduction?

China's national ETS does not generate an Article 9 deduction today. The scheme was extended to steel, cement, and aluminium smelting under the work plan of March 20, 2025, but allowances are 100% freely allocated on an intensity basis, so little or no carbon price is effectively paid, and the scheme has not been recognized. The draft implementing regulation's treatment of baseline-and-credit systems as equivalent to emissions trading could open a pathway once adopted, but that draft remained unadopted as of October 12, 2026, so its conversion rules are not yet binding. Importers of Chinese CBAM goods should not count on an Article 9 deduction in the 2027 declaration cycle.

Does the Article 9 Deduction Reduce the CBAM Certificate Price?

The Article 9 deduction reduces the number of CBAM certificates surrendered, not the price per certificate. CBAM certificate prices track the EU ETS auction price: the official prices are €75.36/tCO₂e for Q1 2026, €75.28 for Q2 and €82.32 for Q3, the last published on October 5, 2026. The deduction formula divides the foreign carbon payment by the CBAM certificate price to convert it into a certificate count reduction.

A higher CBAM certificate price at the time of surrender means a smaller certificate count reduction from the same foreign payment, because each certificate represents more monetary value. Authorized declarants should model the deduction under a range of future ETS prices when planning procurement from countries with a carbon price. Information on CBAM certificates covers the full certificate purchase and surrender cycle.

Is Proof of Effective Payment Mandatory for Every Deduction Claim?

Proof of effective payment is mandatory for every Article 9 deduction claim, without exception. The regulation uses the phrase "effectively paid" to exclude scenarios where a carbon price exists on paper but has not resulted in an actual financial obligation at the installation level, for example installations receiving 100% free allocations under a national ETS that nominally covers them. The documentation must be certified by a person independent from the declarant and from the third-country authorities (Article 9(2)), and the declarant must keep evidence of the actual payment.

Importers planning to claim a deduction for 2026 imports should begin documentation collection now; the declaration deadline is September 30, 2027. The process for how embedded emissions are calculated provides the measurement foundation that the Article 9 deduction calculation rests on.

Are Voluntary Carbon Offsets Eligible for the Article 9 Deduction?

Voluntary carbon offsets are ineligible for the Article 9 deduction. Article 3(29) of Regulation (EU) 2023/956 defines a carbon price as a tax, levy, fee or emission allowances under a greenhouse gas emissions trading system in a third country. Voluntary offset purchases, Gold Standard credits, VCS credits, and internal corporate shadow carbon prices all fall outside this definition. Importers whose suppliers use voluntary offsetting programs as part of their sustainability reporting cannot apply those payments toward any CBAM certificate reduction.


Data sources: Regulation (EU) 2023/956 · Regulation (EU) 2025/2083 (Omnibus) · IR 2025/2621 · EU ETS data via EEX. Not legal advice.