
UK CBAM and EU CBAM are two independent carbon border regimes with no mutual recognition between them, and exporters selling into both markets face separate carbon cost obligations on every qualifying shipment.
As of January 1, 2026, the EU's definitive phase under Regulation (EU) 2023/956 is in force. The UK CBAM starts on January 1, 2027 as a tax under Part 5 of the Finance Act 2026.
For producers that ship to both markets, such as steel mills in India, China, Türkiye and South Korea, this creates two carbon border costs, calculated and reported under different rules. This article examines who is exposed to double payment, how costs stack across both regimes, and what options exist to manage the overlap.
Is the UK CBAM Double-Payment Risk Real?
Yes, the double-payment risk is real, and it is structural: no mutual recognition exists between the EU and UK CBAM regimes, neither credits a charge paid under the other, and exporters who sell identical goods into both markets carry two separate carbon border obligations on separate shipments.
The EU carbon border adjustment mechanism operates through a certificate system priced against EU ETS auction prices; the official quarterly price for Q3 2026 is €82.32/tCO₂e, published October 5, 2026.
The UK CBAM operates as a tax paid to HMRC, at a quarterly sectoral rate built from UK ETS auction prices. The two prices move independently and the two administrative systems are entirely separate.
Neither regime currently credits a charge paid under the other CBAM. The EU's Article 9 covers a carbon price paid in the country of origin, and HMRC's provisional list of qualifying carbon pricing schemes (August 27, 2026) does not include the EU CBAM.
That list does name the EU ETS, which matters for EU-made goods imported into the UK and is covered below.
Under EU CBAM, Article 9 of Regulation (EU) 2023/956 allows authorized declarants to reduce their certificate obligation when the exporter has paid a carbon price in their country of origin.
The question for UK exporters is whether a UK ETS cost or a UK CBAM charge qualifies as such a carbon price. As of October 12, 2026, no Commission implementing regulation has confirmed UK ETS recognition under Article 9.
The Commission's draft implementing regulation setting out the general recognition pathways for third-country carbon prices under Article 9 closed public consultation on June 10, 2026. No adoption had been confirmed as of October 6, 2026, and the draft does not by itself resolve the UK-specific question.
The UK ETS is not linked to the EU ETS. For goods originating in the UK and imported into the EU, the Article 9 deduction is uncertain at best and, in the absence of a bilateral recognition agreement, effectively unavailable.
The EU carbon border adjustment mechanism is designed around the EU ETS framework and grants deductions only for carbon prices paid in the country of production, under schemes recognized by the Commission. The UK ETS remains a separate, unlinked trading system.
Who Faces the Highest UK CBAM and EU CBAM Overlap Exposure?
Three categories of exporters carry the most concentrated double-payment risk under the UK CBAM and EU CBAM overlap.
Exporters selling to both markets simultaneously face the most direct exposure. A Turkish blast furnace steel producer that ships 10,000 tonnes to Germany and 5,000 tonnes to the UK in 2027 incurs EU CBAM on the German shipment and UK CBAM on the UK shipment as two entirely separate obligations.
No netting is possible. The embedded emissions of the steel are calculated under two different methodologies, priced against two different carbon price benchmarks, and reported to two different administrative authorities.
Producers in countries that supply both markets in volume are the second group. Four origins are among the largest non-EU sources of steel for both the EU and the UK. The table gives import statistics for 2025, which measure trade and not CBAM charges.
| Origin | EU27 steel imports, 2025 | UK steel imports, 2025 |
|---|---|---|
| China | 9.07 million tonnes | 780 thousand tonnes |
| Türkiye | 7.43 million tonnes | 671 thousand tonnes |
| India | 4.01 million tonnes | 1.12 million tonnes |
| South Korea | 3.63 million tonnes | 652 thousand tonnes |
Sources: Eurostat Comext DS-045409, EU27 imports of CBAM-covered steel (Annex I goods of Chapters 72 and 73, without iron ore); HMRC Overseas Trade Statistics, UK imports of Chapter 72 without ferro-alloys and scrap plus headings 7301 to 7311, 7318 and 7326. Both extracted October 12, 2026. The two product groups are close but not identical.
UK-based manufacturers using imported CBAM inputs face a different but related problem. A UK steel fabricator who imports Turkish steel billets faces UK CBAM on those billets from January 1, 2027. If the fabricator then re-exports finished steel products to the EU, EU CBAM applies at the EU border.
The carbon costs embedded in the input material have now been priced twice: once under UK CBAM on import to the UK, and once under EU CBAM on export to the EU.
How Do EU CBAM and UK CBAM Costs Stack? A Worked Example
The table below shows the combined carbon border cost for a Turkish blast furnace steel producer shipping 1,000 tonnes to Germany and 1,000 tonnes to the UK in calendar year 2027. The EU side is calculated for semi-finished non-alloy steel (CN 7207 11 14) on the EU default value for Türkiye.
| Obligation | Regime | Emission Factor | Carbon Price | Gross Cost |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Germany shipment (1,000 t BF-BOF steel, CN 7207 11 14) | EU CBAM | 2.772 tCO2e/t (default 2.310 plus the 20% mark-up for 2027) | €82.32/tCO2e (official Q3 2026 price, held constant) | ~€228,191 before the free allocation adjustment |
| UK shipment (1,000 t steel, CN 7207 11 14) | UK CBAM | 2.856 tCO2e/t (UK default value, draft notice of October 16, 2026) | GBP 9.69/tCO2e (HMRC illustrative iron and steel rate, no liability, already net of free allocation) | GBP 27,674.64 |
| Article 9 reduction (EU CBAM) | EU CBAM | Only for a carbon price effectively paid | No Turkish carbon price is recognised, and the Turkish pilot ETS allocates 100% of allowances for free | €0 as of October 12, 2026 |
| Carbon price relief (UK CBAM) | UK CBAM | Applied only if a qualifying scheme priced the emissions | Turkey is not on HMRC's provisional list | Likely £0 |
| Combined exposure | Both | 2,772 + 2,856 = 5,628 tCO2e total | Two separate prices | ~€228,191 (EU, gross) + GBP 27,674.64 (UK, illustrative) |
Note: the EU row uses the official Q3 2026 certificate price of €82.32/tCO₂e, published October 5, 2026; goods imported in 2027 will be priced at weekly averages that are not yet known. The UK row uses the draft UK default value and HMRC's illustrative rate of October 16, 2026, which create no tax liability; the UK rate is already net of free allocation. The EU gross figure shrinks for free allocation by deducting the CBAM factor (95% in 2027) × the benchmark of the good from its embedded emissions.
The net EU CBAM cost of the German shipment is lower than the gross figure because of the free allocation adjustment, but it is not a small percentage of it.
Under IR (EU) 2025/2620, the adjustment for 2027 is the CBAM factor of 95% × the default benchmark of 1.364, which is 1.2958 tCO2e per tonne.
Deducting it from 2.772 leaves 1.4762 certificates per tonne, or about €121,521 for 1,000 tonnes at €82.32. The deduction shrinks each year as the CBAM factor falls, to 51.5% in 2030, and the benchmark may be updated for goods imported from 2027.
The UK CBAM has its own phase-in, built into the price instead of the volume.
Section 149(3) of the Finance Act 2026, Step 2, reduces the average UK ETS auction price by the sector's adjusted free-allocation percentage, which is why HMRC's illustrative iron and steel rate of October 16, 2026 is GBP 9.69 per tonne CO2e against a Q3 2026 UK ETS average of GBP 58.15.
At that rate and the UK default value of 2.856, the 1,000 tonnes would carry GBP 27,674.64 before any carbon price relief. The illustrative rates create no tax liability, binding rates for January to March 2027 follow before the end of 2026, and the UK CBAM rate guide explains them.
What does not change regardless of the CBAM factor is the absence of any offset between the two systems. The roughly €121,500 paid for EU CBAM certificates does not reduce the UK CBAM charge. The UK CBAM charge paid to HMRC does not reduce the EU certificate surrender obligation. They operate independently, in full.
Why No Deduction Exists Between UK CBAM and EU CBAM
The absence of mutual recognition between the UK CBAM and EU CBAM regimes is a structural consequence of how both systems were designed, not an oversight.
The EU CBAM deduction mechanism under Article 9 of Regulation (EU) 2023/956 applies only to a carbon price that "has been effectively paid in a third country" for the declared embedded emissions.
For goods originating in Turkey, that means a Turkish carbon pricing scheme. For goods originating in the UK, a UK carbon pricing scheme could theoretically qualify. The UK operates the UK ETS, which is a qualifying-type scheme in principle.
However, the Commission must formally recognize a third-country carbon pricing system before importers can use it for Article 9 deduction, and the Commission has issued no such recognition for the UK ETS as of October 12, 2026.
A draft implementing regulation setting the general recognition criteria for third-country carbon prices under Article 9 finished public consultation on June 10, 2026, and no adoption had been confirmed as of October 6, 2026.
The UK side does have a relief, but it does not close this gap. Carbon price relief under section 150 of the Finance Act 2026 reduces UK CBAM where the imported good was made at an installation in a qualifying carbon pricing scheme, and HMRC's provisional list of August 27, 2026 names the EU ETS among 16 schemes.
A UK importer of EU-made steel can therefore claim relief for the effective EU ETS price paid, though not for emissions covered by free allowances.
That relief follows the good's own production emissions. It does not reduce UK CBAM because the same exporter paid EU CBAM on other shipments, and the EU has no matching recognition of the UK ETS. The asymmetry is the core of the problem for UK-EU supply chains.
For more on the structural differences between the two systems, the UK CBAM guide covers the design choices, sector coverage, and administrative requirements of the UK regime in full.
Certificate price alerts and the regulatory changes that matter. Get weekly updates on what happens regarding anything CBAM-related. No spam, unsubscribe anytime.
We store only your email address for these alerts. Privacy policy
What Can Exporters Do About the Double-Payment Problem?
Exporters facing UK CBAM and EU CBAM double payment exposure have four practical options, none of which eliminates the overlap entirely.
The practical options available to exporters are described below:
-
Decarbonize production and document it. Lower embedded emissions reduce the carbon border cost under both regimes, but only where the producer supplies verified actual data. On default values the EU charge is fixed by the country default, whatever the mill's real emissions. The saving is also not proportional to the emissions cut: the EU deducts a benchmark that depends on the production route, so a move from the blast furnace to the electric arc route changes both the emissions and the deduction.
-
Segment market supply chains. Producing goods specifically for the UK market and separately for the EU market allows the producer to optimize the production route and emissions profile for each market's pricing methodology. This is operationally complex but can reduce total exposure when the two carbon pricing systems have significantly different price levels.
-
Monitor UK ETS recognition progress. If the UK ETS is formally recognized by the European Commission under Article 9, UK exporters would be able to reduce their EU CBAM certificate obligation by the amount of UK ETS cost embedded in their production. This would not eliminate double payment but would reduce the EU side of the overlap. Monitoring DG TAXUD announcements on third-country carbon price recognition is essential for any exporter in this position.
-
Engage with HMRC and competent authority early. Both the UK CBAM registration process and the EU authorized declarant application require substantial lead time. Exporters shipping to both markets need compliance frameworks in place for both systems before the respective deadlines. For EU CBAM, the importer needs authorized declarant status, and March 31, 2026 was the last date to apply and keep importing provisionally until the decision. For UK CBAM, the importer registers with HMRC once CBAM goods worth £50,000 or more trigger registration; HMRC's guidance says registration will open by January 1, 2028.
How Does the UK CBAM and EU CBAM Overlap Affect Specific Sectors?
Steel: The Highest Double-Payment Exposure Sector
Steel carries the highest combined UK CBAM and EU CBAM double-payment risk of the six sectors covered by the EU scheme, for three reasons.
First, steel default values are high: 2.310 tCO2e per tonne for semi-finished steel from Türkiye on the EU side (before the mark-up) and 2.856 for the same good (CN 7207 11 14) on the UK side, generating large absolute carbon costs in both regimes.
Second, steel is the largest sector by import tonnage in both markets: 57.73 million tonnes entered the EU27 from outside the EU in 2025 (Eurostat Comext) and 9.16 million tonnes entered the UK, 4.30 million of them from outside the EU (HMRC Overseas Trade Statistics), on the product groups defined under the table above.
Third, the same origins supply both markets, and for Türkiye, the second-largest origin on the EU side, no relief is available on either side.
Türkiye published its Emissions Trading System Regulation on August 27, 2026, but the pilot allocates 100% of allowances free, so no carbon price is effectively paid and no Article 9 reduction arises. Türkiye is also absent from HMRC's provisional list of qualifying schemes.
The UK CBAM vs EU CBAM comparison article provides a full breakdown of sector-by-sector differences between the two regimes, including where the UK scheme diverges from the EU model on sector coverage and calculation methodology.
Cement: Türkiye Is the EU's Largest Origin
Türkiye supplied 6.12 million tonnes of cement and clinker to the EU27 in 2025, 43.0% of the EU's imports from outside the bloc by quantity and more than any other origin. Ukraine (13.3%), Algeria (11.9%) and Egypt (11.6%) followed (Eurostat Comext DS-045409, extracted October 12, 2026).
The UK side cannot be ranked by origin from published statistics. The UK imported 4.21 million tonnes of cement and clinker (heading 2523) in 2025, but HMRC's Overseas Trade Statistics record 3.55 million tonnes of that under "Confidential Country". Among the origins that are disclosed, Türkiye accounts for 166 thousand tonnes (extracted October 12, 2026).
Under EU CBAM, Türkiye's own row for grey Portland cement (CN 2523 29 00) shows a dash, so the "Other Countries and Territories" default of 1.440 tCO2e per tonne applies, against a benchmark of 0.666.
For 2026 that is 1.584 with the 10% mark-up, minus 0.975 × 0.666, which leaves 0.93465 certificates per tonne, or €76.94 at the official Q3 2026 price of €82.32.
No country's carbon price is recognised under Article 9, so no reduction applies on the EU side. UK CBAM adds a second carbon border charge on UK-bound shipments.
Is the UK CBAM a Tax or a Certificate System?
The UK CBAM operates as a direct tax charged to importers by HMRC, calculated on the carbon content of imported goods and priced against the UK ETS carbon price. This design differs fundamentally from the EU's certificate-based approach, where importers purchase CBAM certificates on the common central platform and surrender them in the CBAM Registry. The tax-versus-certificate distinction matters for the double-payment question because it means there is no certificate system to offset against and no registry to cross-reference. Any relief between the systems has to come through each side's own rules: Article 9 on the EU side, and carbon price relief or the linked-scheme power in section 156 of the Finance Act 2026 on the UK side.
Does Paying EU CBAM Reduce UK CBAM Liability?
No. Paying EU CBAM certificates does not reduce UK CBAM liability. The two obligations are calculated independently on separate shipments entering separate customs territories. An exporter pays EU CBAM on goods entering the EU and UK CBAM on goods entering the UK. Neither payment has any legal effect on the other.
Will UK ETS Recognition Under Article 9 Ever Happen?
The possibility exists but requires a formal Commission decision recognizing the UK ETS as a qualifying carbon pricing scheme under Article 9 of Regulation (EU) 2023/956. No such decision has been issued as of October 12, 2026. Formal UK-EU negotiations on linking the UK ETS and EU ETS have been underway since January 2026, under Council Decision (EU) 2025/2468 of November 13, 2025.
The negotiation was officially still open on October 13, 2026. POLITICO reported on October 7, 2026 that negotiators had reached agreement on the link; that remains a media report. On October 12, 2026 the Prime Minister told the House of Commons that the UK-EU summit takes place in Brussels on November 20, 2026 and that "a deal on emissions trading" is on the table, without announcing an agreement or a start date. The negotiation record, and the legal steps that would have to follow an agreement, are set out in the guide to UK and EU ETS linkage.
On the UK side, HMRC's policy summary (updated September 9, 2026) states: "There are currently no jurisdictions exempt from CBAM." Section 156 of the Finance Act 2026 gives the Treasury power to exclude goods from a country with a linked scheme, by regulations.
A linking agreement is also a separate legal step from Article 9 recognition. EU officials have indicated that a CBAM exemption for UK-origin goods would only follow once the two ETS systems are fully linked, not merely once a political agreement is announced. The CBAM compliance for importers section of this site tracks regulatory developments affecting the Article 9 deduction, including any third-country recognition announcements.
Which Countries Face the Worst UK-EU CBAM Double Exposure?
No official ranking of double exposure exists, and trade statistics measure imports, not CBAM charges. They do show which origins supply both markets in volume. In 2025 the EU27 imported 9.07 million tonnes of CBAM-covered steel from China, 7.43 million from Türkiye, 4.01 million from India and 3.63 million from South Korea (Eurostat Comext). The UK imported 1.12 million tonnes of steel from India, 780 thousand from China, 671 thousand from Türkiye and 652 thousand from South Korea (HMRC Overseas Trade Statistics; both extracted October 12, 2026).
Türkiye is the only one of those four origins with no scheme on HMRC's provisional list of qualifying schemes on the UK side, and no Turkish carbon price is recognized under Article 9 on the EU side. The China national ETS, India's Carbon Credit Trading Scheme and the Korea ETS are on HMRC's provisional list, so UK relief may be available where a carbon price was effectively paid. Türkiye is also the largest origin of the EU's cement and clinker imports, with 43.0% by quantity in 2025.
What Is the Role of CBAM Certificates in Managing UK-EU Overlap?
CBAM certificates under the EU regime must be purchased, held, and surrendered by authorized declarants according to specific rules: from 2027, the account must hold at each quarter end certificates for at least 50% of the embedded emissions in goods imported since the start of the calendar year, with the free allocation adjustment taken into account (Article 22(2)), and the certificates for the preceding year are surrendered by September 30. No certificate system exists under the UK regime. Managing both obligations requires separate compliance tracks: EU certificates purchased from the Member State on the common central platform from February 1, 2027 (Article 20(1)), and UK tax reporting to HMRC under the UK CBAM's separate administrative framework.
Does the Annual CBAM Declaration Cover Both Regimes?
No. The CBAM declaration under EU CBAM covers only goods imported into the EU customs territory. It is submitted through the CBAM Registry by September 30 each year (Article 6(1)), covering the prior calendar year. The UK obligation is a separate return to HMRC for each accounting period: one return for 2027, due by May 31, 2028, then quarterly returns. Both filings require embedded emissions data, but the calculation methodologies differ between the two regimes, meaning a single verified emissions report may not satisfy both systems without adaptation.