CBAM Russia: WTO Dispute DS639 and What It Means for Fertilizer and Steel Trade

Russia supplied €4.89 billion of CBAM-covered goods to the EU in 2025.

Page contents
Diagram: Russian fertiliser plants count direct and electricity emissions, steel works direct only. The EU importer surrenders certificates for embedded emissions minus free allocation; with no carbon price paid, nothing more is deducted.

CBAM Russia exposure operates on two simultaneous tracks: EU sanctions and tariffs already restrict Russian steel and fertilizers, and the EU carbon border adjustment mechanism established by Regulation (EU) 2023/956 adds a carbon cost on the trade that remains.

That trade is still large: the EU27 imported €4.89 billion of CBAM-covered goods (Annex I codes) from Russia in 2025, 10.40 million tonnes, the seventh-largest origin by value (Eurostat, Comext DS-045409, extracted October 12, 2026).

Russia responded to CBAM by filing WTO DS639 on May 12, 2025, the only formal CBAM challenge filed by any country to date, and escalated it with a panel establishment request on July 10, 2026, which the EU blocked at the July 24, 2026 DSB meeting.

The DSB established the panel on Russia's second request on September 25, 2026, under the reverse-consensus rule of DSU Article 6.1. The WTO case page showed no panel composition as of October 12, 2026.

Understanding how these two layers interact is essential for EU importers of Russian-origin fertilizers and steel who are planning compliance for the September 30, 2027 declaration deadline.

This article covers Russia's CBAM-exposed sectors, the DS639 dispute mechanics, the Article 9 deduction status, and the real compliance burden facing EU importers in 2026 and beyond.


What Is the CBAM Russia Situation in 2026?

Russia is the only country that has filed a formal WTO challenge against the EU Carbon Border Adjustment Mechanism, making its position structurally different from other affected exporters such as India, Turkey, and China.

Russia's CBAM exposure is concentrated in fertilizers, semi-finished steel and aluminium: of the 2025 import value of CBAM-covered goods from Russia, iron and steel made up 44.0%, fertilizers 40.5% and aluminium 15.4% (Eurostat Comext, 2025). Sanctions and tariffs restrict parts of the same trade, which adds legal and compliance complexity to the carbon cost.

The EU carbon border adjustment mechanism came into its definitive phase on January 1, 2026. Importers who bring Russian-origin fertilizers or steel above the 50-tonne annual de minimis threshold into the EU are now subject to full CBAM obligations.

The first CBAM declaration covering calendar year 2026 is due September 30, 2027, and certificate purchases begin February 1, 2027.

Russia has no carbon price recognised under Article 9 of Regulation (EU) 2023/956, and neither has any other country as of October 12, 2026, because the implementing act is still a draft.

Russia has no nationwide carbon price. Its quota scheme is a regional experiment in Sakhalin Oblast under Federal Law No. 34-FZ of March 6, 2022, which runs from September 1, 2022 to December 31, 2028.

The Moscow Times reported on October 26, 2023 that quotas for 2024 to 2028 covered 35 companies, with a payment of 1,000 rubles for each tonne above the quota. This means EU importers of Russian-origin goods cannot claim any Article 9 reduction when calculating their CBAM certificate obligation.


CBAM country card for Russia, as of October 26, 2026. In 2025 the EU imported €4.89 billion of CBAM-covered goods from Russia, the 7th largest non-EU origin by value (10.40 million tonnes, 4th by quantity). Largest goods by quantity: semi-finished steel (CN 7207) 3,726 thousand tonnes; urea (CN 3102 10) 1,903 thousand tonnes; nPK fertilisers (CN 3105 20) 1,091 thousand tonnes; pig iron (CN 7201) 700 thousand tonnes; ammonia (CN 2814) 683 thousand tonnes. Worked example for urea (CN 3102 10 19) imported in 2026 on the default value: default value 1.470 tCO2e per tonne, 1.4847 with the mark-up, minus a free allocation adjustment of 0.87945, gives 0.60525 certificates per tonne, or €49.82 per tonne at the Q3 2026 price of €82.32. Russia has its own default values. The Russia table in Annex I has a value for each of the five goods above, so the “Other countries and territories” defaults do not apply to them. No deduction. Russia has no effective carbon pricing (as of October 23, 2026). Separately, Russian fertilisers of CN 3102 and six CN 3105 subheadings pay the customs duty of Regulation (EU) 2025/1227, which is not CBAM. Sources: Eurostat Comext DS-045409; Implementing Regulation (EU) 2025/2621 as replaced by 2026/1740; Implementing Regulation (EU) 2025/2620.
Source: Trade: Eurostat Comext DS-045409, 2025 (extracted October 12, 2026). Default values: Implementing Regulation (EU) 2025/2621, Annex I, as replaced by Implementing Regulation (EU) 2026/1740. Benchmarks: Implementing Regulation (EU) 2025/2620. Q3 2026 certificate price €82.32 (Article 21(1a), Regulation (EU) 2023/956). · As of October 26, 2026
Text version of this infographic

- €4.89 billion: EU imports of CBAM-covered goods from Russia, 2025 (10.40 million tonnes. Trade statistics, not CBAM declarations)

- 7th: largest non-EU origin by value (4th by quantity, of all non-EU origins)

What the EU imports most from Russia

- Semi-finished steel, 7207: 3,726

- Urea, 3102 10: 1,903

- NPK fertilisers, 3105 20: 1,091

- Pig iron, 7201: 700

- Ammonia, 2814: 683

Thousand tonnes in 2025, by CN code. Highlighted: the worked example below.

What one tonne costs in 2026

Urea, CN 3102 10 19 (Imported from Russia in 2026, on the default value. Figures in tCO₂e per tonne)

- Default value, Russia table: 1.470

- Plus 1% mark-up (fertilisers, every year): 1.4847

- Minus free allocation adjustment (97.5% × benchmark 0.902): −0.87945

- Certificates per tonne: 0.60525

Cost per tonne at the Q3 2026 price of €82.32: €49.82

The old shortcut, 2.5% of gross, says €3.06. It is wrong: the deduction stops at the benchmark, and everything above it is paid in full.

Russia has its own default values. The Russia table in Annex I has a value for each of the five goods above, so the “Other countries and territories” defaults do not apply to them.

No deduction. Russia has no effective carbon pricing (as of October 23, 2026). Separately, Russian fertilisers of CN 3102 and six CN 3105 subheadings pay the customs duty of Regulation (EU) 2025/1227, which is not CBAM.

Russia's CBAM-Exposed Sectors: Trade Volumes and Embedded Emissions

Russia's two primary CBAM sectors are fertilizers and steel. Both carry high embedded emissions relative to their export price, and both face stacked trade barriers in 2026.

The EU27 imported 4.92 million tonnes of CBAM-covered fertilizers from Russia in 2025, worth €1.98 billion: 24.5% of extra-EU imports by quantity and the largest origin, including 1.90 million tonnes of urea and 682 thousand tonnes of ammonia.

Iron and steel came to 5.17 million tonnes (€2.15 billion), almost all of it crude and semi-finished steel (3.87 million tonnes, 38.0% of extra-EU imports of those goods) and pig iron, ferro-alloys and direct reduced iron (1.28 million tonnes). Unwrought aluminium was 303 thousand tonnes (Eurostat Comext, 2025).

The table below shows the cost of Russian goods declared on the Russian Federation's own default values in Annex I to Implementing Regulation (EU) 2025/2621, as replaced by Implementing Regulation (EU) 2026/1740, at the official Q3 2026 certificate price of €82.32, published October 5, 2026.

Product (CN code) Default value (tCO₂e/t) Default plus 2026 mark-up Benchmark Certificates per tonne 2026 Cost per tonne 2026 at €82.32 Cost per tonne 2030 at constant price Tariff, sanctions and trade status
Urea (CN 3102 10 19) 1.470 1.485 0.902 0.605 €49.82 €83.98 Duty of Regulation (EU) 2025/1227 on CN 3102: 6.5% + €60/t from July 1, 2026, €80/t from July 1, 2027, €315/t from July 1, 2028
Ammonium nitrate (CN 3102 30 90) 2.600 2.626 0.767 1.878 €154.61 €183.66 Same duty (CN 3102)
Semi-finished steel (CN 7207 11 14) 3.210 3.531 1.364 2.201 €181.19 €285.69 Imports continue: 3.87 million tonnes of crude and semi-finished steel in 2025 (Eurostat Comext)
Hot-rolled flat steel (CN 7208) 3.430 3.773 1.370 2.437 €200.63 €308.98 EU sanctions; no imports recorded in 2025 (Eurostat Comext)
Unwrought aluminium (CN 7601, RUSAL) 2.160 2.376 1.423 0.989 €81.38 €170.83 303 thousand tonnes in 2025 (Eurostat Comext); partial sanctions restrictions apply

Certificates per tonne equal the default plus the mark-up, minus the free allocation adjustment (CBAM factor × cross-sectoral correction factor × the Column B benchmark of Implementing Regulation (EU) 2025/2620). Inputs for 2026: mark-up 10% (1% for fertilizers), CBAM factor 97.5%, correction factor 100%, blast furnace route (C) for steel and primary route (K) for aluminium. The 2030 column uses a 30% mark-up (1% for fertilizers) and a CBAM factor of 51.5%, with the price and the benchmarks held constant; the benchmarks may be updated from 2027. No Article 9 reduction applies. Figures are rounded to three decimals and costs are computed from the unrounded figures.

Russia's default for anhydrous ammonia (CN 2814 10 00) is 2.260 tCO₂e/t, which costs €65.74 per tonne in 2026 on the same method, with a benchmark of 1.522. Ammonia (CN 2814) is not in Annex II of Regulation (EU) 2025/1227, so the fertilizer duty described below does not apply to it.

Every Russian carbon steel row carries the blast furnace route, so the blast furnace benchmark is deducted on default values even where the mill runs an electric arc furnace.

Fertilizers include both direct and indirect embedded emissions under CBAM. Ammonia and urea production via the Haber-Bosch process generates CO₂ from natural gas reforming, and ammonia carries CO₂ only.

N₂O is covered where it arises in production, where nitric acid is part of the process (nitrate fertilizers); N₂O from field application is not an embedded emission. CBAM steel covers direct emissions only, which means indirect electricity emissions from Russian electric arc furnaces are not included in the CBAM certificate calculation.

The stacked cost for Russian urea reaching an EU buyer in 2026 combines the customs duty of Regulation (EU) 2025/1227 and the CBAM cost.

For goods of CN 3102, urea included, the duty is 6.5% ad valorem plus €40 per tonne from July 1, 2025 to June 30, 2026, and 6.5% plus €60 per tonne from July 1, 2026 to June 30, 2027.

On the Russian default value for urea (CN 3102 10 19), 1.470 tCO₂e/t plus the 1% fertilizer mark-up is 1.4847. The free allocation adjustment is the CBAM factor of 97.5% × the benchmark of 0.902, or 0.87945, which leaves 0.60525 certificates per tonne: €49.82 at €82.32.

At a constant price that rises to €83.98 for 2030 imports, when the CBAM factor is 51.5%. From July 1, 2028 the duty alone is 6.5% plus €315 per tonne.


WTO DS639: The First Formal CBAM Challenge

Russia filed DS639 on May 12, 2025, becoming the first country to formally challenge CBAM at the World Trade Organization. The dispute is the most important legal development in CBAM history and the subject of significant analysis in the broader CBAM WTO compatibility literature. DS639 raises four distinct legal arguments against Regulation (EU) 2023/956.

The 4 legal allegations filed under WTO DS639 are listed below.

  • GATT Article I (Most-Favored-Nation): Russia argues CBAM discriminates between countries based on whether they have a domestic carbon pricing scheme, creating unequal treatment across WTO members.
  • GATT Article II (Tariff Bindings): Russia argues CBAM constitutes a charge beyond bound tariff rates, effectively imposing a second layer of market access conditions not agreed in WTO schedules.
  • SCM Agreement (Subsidies): Russia argues EU ETS free allocation to domestic EU producers constitutes a prohibited or actionable subsidy that disadvantages Russian exporters.
  • GATT Article III (National Treatment): Russia argues CBAM treats imported goods less favorably than domestically produced equivalent goods, violating the national treatment principle.

The EU declined consultations on May 22, 2025, stating they "could not be fruitful." This response is procedurally unusual. Under the WTO Dispute Settlement Understanding, consultation acceptance is typically a formality. By declining, the EU indicated it viewed DS639 primarily as a political challenge rather than a substantive legal dispute amenable to negotiated resolution.

Russia exercised its next procedural step on July 10, 2026, requesting establishment of a panel.

At the DSB meeting of July 24, 2026, the EU objected to this first panel request, so no panel was established then: under WTO practice a respondent can block only the first request. The EU also reconfirmed its refusal of consultations, citing Russia's invasion of Ukraine.

Russia resubmitted, and the DSB established the panel at its meeting of September 25, 2026: DSU Article 6.1 requires the DSB to establish a panel no later than the meeting at which the request appears on the agenda for the second time, unless it decides by reverse consensus not to, a consensus Russia itself would have had to join.

The establishment makes DS639 the first border carbon adjustment dispute anywhere with an established WTO panel, with claims spanning GATT Articles I, II, III, X and XI, the Import Licensing Agreement, and the SCM Agreement, including the claim that EU ETS free allocation operates as a prohibited export subsidy.

As of October 12, 2026, the WTO case page shows no panel composition and lists 27 members that reserved third-party rights, including China, India, Türkiye, the United Kingdom and the United States. Standard WTO timelines place any panel report in the 2027 to 2028 horizon.

The filing is covered in Russia requests WTO panel establishment in DS639, the establishment in WTO establishes DS639 panel on EU CBAM, and the full procedural timeline is in the dedicated WTO DS639 reference article.

Does DS639 Have Enforcement Potential?

DS639 has no realistic near-term enforcement mechanism. The WTO Appellate Body has been non-functional since December 2019 due to the United States blocking new appointments to fill vacant seats. Any panel ruling in DS639 can be appealed by the EU into a permanent procedural void. The EU participates in the Multi-Party Interim Appeal Arbitration Arrangement (MPIA), the stand-in appeal channel among its participants, but Russia does not, so the arrangement does not apply to DS639. Even if a panel rules in Russia's favor, the EU can appeal and the report cannot be adopted.

The practical function of DS639 is therefore political and signaling, not compliance-coercive. Russia uses it as part of its broader diplomatic positioning on the Ukraine conflict sanctions regime, as a demonstration that CBAM is contested law, and as a tool to support the narrative among BRICS countries that CBAM represents Western carbon protectionism. That narrative gained formal multilateral expression on August 18, 2026, when Russia joined the BRICS Environment Ministers' statement opposing carbon border measures, a collective declaration that runs alongside Russia's solo litigation track in DS639 and is covered in the report on the BRICS condemnation of CBAM.

The EU's legal defense rests on GATT Article XX(b), the exception for measures "necessary to protect human, animal or plant life or health," and Article XX(g), the exception for measures "relating to the conservation of exhaustible natural resources." Whether CBAM satisfies the requirements of these exceptions, particularly the "least trade-restrictive" necessity test, remains contested among international trade law scholars.


The CBAM newsletter

Certificate price alerts and the regulatory changes that matter. Get weekly updates on what happens regarding anything CBAM-related. No spam, unsubscribe anytime.

We store only your email address for these alerts. Privacy policy

How the Fertilizer Duty and CBAM Interact for Russian Fertilizer Exporters

Russian fertilizers are not banned from the EU. Two separate instruments price them at the border: a customs duty adopted in 2025 and CBAM.

Regulation (EU) 2025/1227 of June 17, 2025 sets the duty on fertilizers originating in or exported from Russia or Belarus.

It covers the goods of its Annex II: CN 3102 (nitrogenous fertilizers, which include urea, ammonium nitrate and urea ammonium nitrate solutions) and CN 3105 20, 3105 30, 3105 40, 3105 51, 3105 59 and 3105 90. Ammonia (CN 2814) and nitric acid (CN 2808) are not in that annex, so the duty does not apply to them. The rates under Article 1(2) are set out below.

Period CN 3102 CN 3105 20, 3105 30, 3105 40, 3105 51, 3105 59, 3105 90
July 1, 2025 to June 30, 2026 6.5% ad valorem + €40/t 6.5% ad valorem + €45/t
July 1, 2026 to June 30, 2027 6.5% ad valorem + €60/t 6.5% ad valorem + €70/t
July 1, 2027 to June 30, 2028 6.5% ad valorem + €80/t 6.5% ad valorem + €95/t
From July 1, 2028 6.5% ad valorem + €315/t 6.5% ad valorem + €430/t

If cumulative imports of these goods reach 2.7 million tonnes in the first period, 1.8 million tonnes in the second or 0.9 million tonnes in the third, the Commission applies the top rate to the remaining imports of that period (Article 1(3)).

Calendar-year imports did not fall at first: the EU27 imported 1.90 million tonnes of Russian urea in 2025, against 1.72 million tonnes in 2024. The drop came in 2026, with 114 thousand tonnes in January to July against 1.39 million tonnes a year earlier (Eurostat Comext monthly data, extracted October 12, 2026).

CBAM adds a further layer on the volume that still enters the EU. EU importers of Russian urea must, under Regulation (EU) 2023/956, report the embedded emissions of that urea and surrender CBAM certificates proportional to those emissions at the EU ETS price.

For CBAM fertilizer exporters of all nationalities, this represents a material cost calculation, but for Russian-origin fertilizers the CBAM obligation sits above an already high tariff burden.

The duty schedule and CBAM together give EU importers strong incentives to source elsewhere. Egypt (3.29 million tonnes) and Algeria (1.17 million tonnes) were the first and third origins of the EU27's urea imports in 2025, and Morocco supplied 1.40 million tonnes of mixed fertilizers (Eurostat Comext, 2025). For those origins CBAM is the main border cost.


What Does CBAM Mean for EU Importers of Russian Steel and Fertilizers?

EU importers of Russian-origin CBAM goods face obligations under Regulation (EU) 2023/956 regardless of whether Russia's WTO challenge succeeds. The CBAM is in force. DS639 does not suspend it.

Importers who sourced Russian steel or fertilizers in calendar year 2026 above the 50-tonne annual de minimis threshold must include those goods in their first CBAM declaration, due September 30, 2027.

The 5 practical steps for EU importers dealing with CBAM Russia obligations are listed below.

  1. Verify authorization status: As an EU importer, confirm you hold authorized declarant status (application deadline was March 31, 2026). A person other than an authorized declarant that brings in CBAM goods pays three to five times the Article 26(1) penalty for each certificate not surrendered, which is €300 to €500 per tonne CO₂e before indexation (Article 26(2)).
  2. Determine embedded emissions: For Russian-origin goods, obtain verified embedded emissions data from the Russian production installation, or apply official CBAM default values from Implementing Regulation (EU) 2025/2621, as replaced by Implementing Regulation (EU) 2026/1740, with the applicable mark-up (10% for steel, cement, aluminium, and hydrogen in 2026; 1% for fertilizers).
  3. Calculate Article 9 deduction: No Article 9 reduction is available, because no country's carbon price is recognised as of October 12, 2026. The certificates owed are the embedded emissions minus the free allocation adjustment, priced for 2026 imports at the official quarterly certificate price (Article 21(1a)).
  4. Hold certificates: From 2027, the account must hold at each quarter-end certificates for at least 50% of the embedded emissions in goods imported since the start of the calendar year, with the free allocation adjustment taken into account (Article 22(2)). No holding requirement applies to 2026 imports.
  5. Report and surrender: Include Russian-origin goods in the September 30, 2027 CBAM declaration and surrender certificates covering 2026 embedded emissions.

The CBAM for non-EU exporters guidance provides a detailed breakdown of how embedded emissions data flows between production installations and EU declarants, including the monitoring plan requirement that Russian producers must satisfy to provide verified data rather than defaults.


CBAM Russia: The Contextual Border with Broader CBAM Trade Law

Russia's position in CBAM trade law is unique because it is the only WTO member litigating against the mechanism. The EU27 imported €4.89 billion of CBAM-covered goods from Russia in 2025, against €17.09 billion from China, €10.83 billion from Türkiye and €5.30 billion from India (Eurostat Comext, 2025).

Those larger suppliers have raised CBAM in bilateral and multilateral forums and have not filed a dispute. Russia chose litigation, and the EU declined consultations with it.

This contextual distinction matters for how EU importers interpret the DS639 challenge. The dispute is not a credible near-term mechanism that will alter CBAM compliance requirements. EU importers sourcing from Russia cannot rely on DS639 as grounds to defer compliance.

Is Russia Eligible for CBAM Exemptions?

Russia is not eligible for any CBAM exemption as of October 12, 2026. Regulation (EU) 2023/956 exempts only goods originating in the countries and territories listed in Annex III, point 1 (Iceland, Liechtenstein, Norway, Switzerland and five territories) under Article 2(4), and a country can be added only where it applies the EU ETS or has an agreement fully linking its system to it (Article 2(6)). Russia meets none of these criteria. Russia has no nationwide carbon price, only the regional experiment in Sakhalin Oblast, and no country's carbon price is recognised under Article 9.

Could Russia Establish a Qualifying Carbon Price?

Russia could in theory establish a domestic carbon price that supports an Article 9 reduction under Regulation (EU) 2023/956, but this is not a realistic near-term scenario. Article 9 requires a carbon price that is "effectively paid" on embedded emissions in the country of origin. The scheme behind it must be legally binding, enforced, and capable of generating verifiable per-installation payment records. Given the current geopolitical context, bilateral regulatory cooperation between Russia and the EU required for Article 9 recognition is not operational.

South Korea's K-ETS shows the timeline involved. It has operated since 2015 and is still not recognised under Article 9 as of October 12, 2026, while the implementing act remains a draft. A Russian scheme would start far behind that institutional track.

How Does DS639 Relate to Other CBAM Challenges?

DS639 is the only formal WTO dispute against CBAM as of October 12, 2026. India and Türkiye have not filed one: both reserved third-party rights in DS639, per the WTO case page. The Commission's review report of December 16, 2025 (COM(2025) 783) lists CBAM dialogues under the EU-India Trade and Technology Council and the EU-Türkiye Customs Union Joint Committee, the bilateral route those countries have used. DS639 is therefore the most procedurally advanced challenge, even though it faces the Appellate Body blockage described above.

For EU importers, the practical implication of this landscape is that no CBAM challenge is expected to produce a suspension or modification of compliance requirements before the first declaration deadline of September 30, 2027. CBAM compliance planning should proceed on current regulation terms.


Frequently Asked Questions: CBAM Russia

What is CBAM Russia exposure and which sectors does it affect?

CBAM Russia exposure covers fertilizers (CN codes 2814, 3102 and 3105), semi-finished steel (CN 7207), pig iron (CN 7201), direct reduced iron (CN 7203) and unwrought aluminium (CN 7601) as the primary flows. The EU27 imported €4.89 billion of CBAM-covered goods from Russia in 2025: 4.92 million tonnes of fertilizers, 5.17 million tonnes of iron and steel and 304 thousand tonnes of aluminium (Eurostat Comext DS-045409, extracted October 12, 2026). Finished Chapter 72 steel products, which EU sanctions restrict, came to 19 thousand tonnes. The compliance obligation applies to all imports above the 50-tonne de minimis threshold.

Does WTO DS639 suspend CBAM obligations for Russian-origin goods?

No. WTO DS639 filed by Russia on May 12, 2025 does not suspend or modify any EU importer's obligation under Regulation (EU) 2023/956. CBAM is in force in its definitive phase since January 1, 2026. DS639 is a consultations and panel process that, even if it proceeds to a ruling, would not automatically suspend CBAM. EU importers of Russian-origin fertilizers and steel must comply with all CBAM reporting and certificate obligations on the standard timetable.

Can EU importers apply an Article 9 deduction for Russian-origin goods?

No. No country's carbon price is recognised under Article 9 of Regulation (EU) 2023/956 as of October 12, 2026, because the implementing act is still a draft. Article 9(1) allows a reduction only for a carbon price effectively paid in the country of origin, with any rebate or other compensation taken into account. EU importers of Russian-origin goods therefore surrender certificates for the embedded emissions after the free allocation adjustment, with no Article 9 reduction.

What is the combined cost for EU importers of Russian urea in 2026?

The combined cost for EU importers of Russian urea in 2026 consists of the customs duty of Regulation (EU) 2025/1227 and a CBAM cost of €49.82/t on default values at the official Q3 2026 certificate price of €82.32. The duty on CN 3102 goods is 6.5% plus €40/t until June 30, 2026 and 6.5% plus €60/t from July 1, 2026, rising to 6.5% plus €315/t from July 1, 2028. The Russian default for urea (CN 3102 10 19) is 1.470 tCO₂e/t, or 1.4847 with the 1% mark-up. The free allocation adjustment is the CBAM factor of 97.5% × the benchmark of 0.902, which leaves 0.60525 certificates per tonne. At a constant price the CBAM cost reaches €83.98/t for 2030 imports.

Is Russia the only country to challenge CBAM at the WTO?

Yes, Russia is the only country that has filed a formal WTO dispute against CBAM as of October 12, 2026. India and Türkiye have not filed one: both are among the 27 members that reserved third-party rights in DS639, per the WTO case page. The EU-India Free Trade Agreement concluded on January 27, 2026 contains no CBAM exemption or carve-out for India.

DS639 filed May 12, 2025 remains the sole formal WTO dispute initiated against Regulation (EU) 2023/956; Russia requested panel establishment on July 10, 2026, the EU blocked that first request at the July 24, 2026 DSB meeting, and the DSB established the panel on Russia's second request on September 25, 2026, by reverse consensus under DSU Article 6.1. The WTO case page showed no panel composition as of October 12, 2026.


Data sources: Regulation (EU) 2023/956 · Regulation (EU) 2025/2083 (Omnibus) · IR 2025/2621 · EU ETS data via EEX. Not legal advice.