CBAM Impact on Aluminium Exporters: Direct Emissions Only, But Defaults Hurt

CBAM prices only direct emissions and PFCs for aluminium, not smelter electricity.

Page contents
Diagram: primary aluminium (route K, CO2 and PFCs, anode effects monitored) and secondary aluminium (route L, remelted scrap, not a CBAM good) give ingots, the extruder's precursor: verified smelter or remelter data, or default values.

CBAM aluminium exporters face a compliance structure that diverges sharply from every other covered sector: only direct emissions and perfluorocarbons are priced, not the electricity that can account for 80% or more of the metal's total carbon footprint.

That structural feature, embedded in Annex II of Regulation (EU) 2023/956, creates a significant advantage for non-EU aluminium producers on paper.

The reality is more complicated. Default values published under Implementing Regulation (EU) 2025/2621 cover direct emissions only, vary widely by country (1.870 tCO₂e per tonne of unwrought aluminium for the UAE, 3.000 for China), and carry a 10% mark-up in 2026, rising to 30% from 2028.

For primary aluminium producers who cannot provide verified actual emissions data, those defaults translate into CBAM costs that bear no resemblance to what direct measurement would show.

This article covers the emissions scope that applies to CBAM aluminium, how default values are set and what they cost producers who do not verify, the cost difference between primary and secondary aluminium, and the practical steps non-EU exporters can take to protect their EU market position.


What CBAM Actually Prices for Aluminium

CBAM for aluminium prices direct process emissions and perfluorocarbons only, not the electricity consumed during smelting. Aluminium is listed in Annex II of Regulation (EU) 2023/956, which restricts CBAM liability to direct emissions under Article 7(1). Indirect emissions from electricity are excluded.

Two perfluorocarbons are covered alongside CO₂: CF₄ (tetrafluoromethane), which carries a global warming potential of 6,630, and C₂F₆ (hexafluoroethane), with a GWP of 11,100. Both are produced during "anode effect" events in the Hall-Héroult electrolysis process when alumina feed concentration drops below threshold.

Modern primary smelters have substantially reduced anode effects through process control improvements, but legacy facilities in China, Russia, and Gulf Cooperation Council countries still generate material PFC emissions.

The practical consequence of excluding electricity is profound. Primary aluminium smelting consumes approximately 14 to 16 MWh per tonne of metal. A smelter operating on a coal-heavy grid at 0.7 tCO₂ per MWh generates roughly 11 tCO₂ from electricity alone.

Under CBAM, that electricity-linked carbon goes unpriced. The EU's legal justification is that EU aluminium producers already receive state aid compensation for indirect carbon costs under Article 10a(6) of the ETS Directive. Including indirect CBAM costs while compensating domestic producers would create asymmetry.

Article 30(2)(a)(i) of the Regulation required the Commission to assess extending the scope to the indirect emissions embedded in Annex II goods.

A technical study on indirect emissions in the CBAM, published by DG TAXUD in June 2026, examined whether and how indirect-emissions coverage could be extended to further CBAM goods. As of October 12, 2026, aluminium is still listed in Annex II and its indirect emissions carry no CBAM obligation.

This is the indirect loophole that distinguishes CBAM aluminium from CBAM cement or fertilizers, both of which price electricity consumption. For the EU carbon border adjustment mechanism as a whole, aluminium represents the clearest case where scope design determines competitive impact.


Why Default Values Punish Primary Aluminium Exporters

Default values are the fallback calculation used when a non-EU installation operator cannot or does not provide verified specific embedded emissions data. For CBAM aluminium exporters relying on defaults, the financial outcome is systematically worse than what actual measurement would deliver.

The default value for unwrought aluminium (CN 7601) is set per country: 1.870 tCO₂e per tonne for the UAE and Bahrain, 1.700 for Türkiye, 3.000 for China and 2.203 for origins without a row of their own, all on the primary route (K).

Rough industry intensities for modern Hall-Héroult smelters run from 1.5 to 2.1 tCO₂e per tonne of direct emissions (rough intensities for context, not default values, benchmarks or verified figures).

The mark-up schedule under IR 2025/2621 adds 10% to the default in 2026, 20% in 2027, and 30% from 2028 onward. A smelter whose verified emissions are below its country default is assessed at a figure that moves further from its own each year.

The reason defaults overstate actual direct emissions for many producers connects to how they are constructed. Default values incorporate data from the full range of operating facilities, including the least efficient, and the calculation methodology for aluminium includes PFC contributions that vary enormously by installation age and smelting practice.

An exporter operating a modern facility with tight anode effect control will have actual direct emissions well below the country-level or global default, but they absorb the same default penalty if they do not submit verified data.

The financial gap exists from the first year. The legal CBAM factor is 97.5% in 2026, the share of free allocation retained, and the free allocation adjustment is 0.975 × the benchmark of 1.423 tCO₂e per tonne for primary unwrought aluminium, a fixed 1.3874 per tonne.

On default values, UAE aluminium (1.870 × 1.10 = 2.057) owes 0.670 certificates per tonne, or €55.12 at the official Q3 2026 price of €82.32.

For 2030 imports, with a 30% mark-up and a CBAM factor of 51.5%, the same metal costs €139.79 per tonne at a constant €82.32, on today's benchmark, which may be updated for goods imported from 2027 (recital 10 of IR (EU) 2025/2620).

The CBAM aluminium guide provides the sector-level CN code breakdown and calculation methodology in full.


Primary vs Secondary Aluminium: Cost Comparison

The CBAM cost divergence between primary and secondary aluminium is the most commercially significant structural difference in the sector.

Secondary aluminium, produced by re-melting recycled scrap, carries direct embedded emissions of approximately 0.05 to 0.1 tCO₂e per tonne (a rough industry figure). That is 15 to 30 times lower than primary aluminium on a direct emissions basis.

The table below compares the default-value path for primary-route and secondary-route origins at the official Q3 2026 certificate price of €82.32 per tonne CO₂e. With default values the route is the one printed in the country's Annex I row: (K), primary, for the UAE and China, and (L), secondary, for Japan and South Korea.

Annex I row (CN 7601) Default (tCO₂e/t) With 10% mark-up Column B benchmark Certificates per tonne, 2026 Cost per tonne, 2026
UAE, primary route (K) 1.870 2.057 1.423 0.670 €55.12
China, primary route (K) 3.000 3.300 1.423 1.913 €157.44
Japan or South Korea, secondary route (L) 0.360 0.396 0.091 0.307 €25.29

Defaults: Annex I to IR (EU) 2025/2621 as replaced by IR (EU) 2026/1740. Benchmarks: IR (EU) 2025/2620, point 5.3. Certificates = default with mark-up minus 0.975 × benchmark.

Secondary aluminium's low embedded emissions stem from two reinforcing factors. First, recycled scrap is treated as a zero-emissions input: its embedded carbon has already been counted upstream. Second, the energy required to re-melt aluminium is a fraction of what electrolysis requires, meaning even the direct emissions from the re-melting furnace are minimal.

For non-EU exporters, the gap between primary and secondary aluminium CBAM costs creates a structural incentive to increase recycled content in export goods. Each percentage point of scrap substitution in the melt reduces the declared specific embedded emissions.

Exporters with documented high scrap rates can use that ratio to claim lower embedded emissions per tonne, provided the calculation follows the methodology in IR 2025/2547.


CBAM Cost Calculation for Aluminium Exporters

The CBAM cost for aluminium follows the standard formula: certificates per tonne = specific embedded emissions minus the free allocation adjustment (CBAM factor × cross-sectoral correction factor × benchmark), priced at the official certificate price. That price is €82.32 per tonne CO₂e for Q3 2026, the quarterly average under Article 21(1a) of Regulation (EU) 2023/956.

For UAE primary aluminium on default values, the 2026 figure is 2.057 tCO₂e per tonne (1.870 plus the 10% mark-up). Before the free allocation adjustment that is €169.33 per tonne at €82.32; after deducting 0.975 × 1.423 = 1.3874, the importer owes 0.670 certificates, or €55.12 per tonne.

A smelter that provides verified actual values replaces the marked-up default with its own figure. For unwrought aluminium the Column A and Column B benchmarks are the same, 1.423 on the primary route, so the deduction is the same on both paths and every verified tonne of CO₂e below the marked-up default saves one certificate.

Rough intensities such as 1.5 tCO₂e per tonne are not verified inputs, so no saving is priced here.

Non-EU exporters should note that the gross CBAM cost is not a cost they pay directly. The CBAM for non-EU exporters page explains the legal structure: the obligation to surrender certificates falls on the EU authorized declarant.

The exporter's exposure is commercial, not legal. EU buyers faced with higher CBAM costs from suppliers unable to provide verified emissions data renegotiate purchase prices downward or substitute to lower-emission suppliers.


What Non-EU Aluminium Exporters Must Provide

Non-EU aluminium installation operators have no direct legal obligation under CBAM. The commercial reality requires engagement regardless. EU importers need specific embedded emissions data from the production installation to avoid punitive default values. Exporters who provide verified data give their EU buyers a cost advantage over competitors relying on defaults.

The data requirements for aluminium installations under IR 2025/2547 cover four areas. First, installation identification: full legal name, physical address, UN/LOCODE, and coordinates of the production facility. Second, production route classification: Hall-Héroult is the standard route for primary aluminium; the monitoring plan must define system boundaries.

Third, specific direct embedded emissions: tonnes CO₂e per tonne of aluminium produced, determined with the calculation-based methodology (standard method or mass balance method) or the measurement-based methodology of Annex II to IR (EU) 2025/2547.

Fourth, PFC reporting: CF₄ and C₂F₆ emissions determined under point B.7 of that Annex and converted to CO₂e using the applicable GWP factors.

Official sector-level instructions for producing this data arrived on August 14, 2026, when the Commission published ten guidance documents for the definitive period.

Guidance No 2 is a quick guide written specifically for non-EU operators, Guidance No 3 covers the embedded-emissions calculation methods, and sector guide 5e applies those methods to aluminium production routes, giving operators the monitoring and calculation instructions for the data they must hand EU importers for the 2026 reporting year.

The full series is covered in the news report on the ten CBAM guidance documents.

The two strategic options for aluminium exporters are listed below.

  • Submit verified actual data via the CBAM Operators Portal: reduces the EU importer's CBAM cost, eliminates the default mark-up, and directly protects the export price. Verification by a verifier accredited by an EU national accreditation body (against EN ISO/IEC 17029:2019) requires a physical site visit in the first year the installation is subject to verification.
  • Accept default values: no upfront cost, but the importer uses the marked-up default, passes the extra cost back as a lower purchase price, and the disadvantage compounds from 2027 as the mark-up increases to 20% and then 30%.

Exporters who complete the CBAM Operators Portal registration and upload verified installation data make that data available to all EU buyer relationships simultaneously. A single verification exercise serves multiple importer accounts.


The CBAM newsletter

Certificate price alerts and the regulatory changes that matter. Get weekly updates on what happens regarding anything CBAM-related. No spam, unsubscribe anytime.

We store only your email address for these alerts. Privacy policy

Which Countries Are Most Affected

CBAM aluminium exporters face different levels of exposure depending on their production technology and their country's default value. The figures below are Eurostat data for 2025 on EU27 imports of CBAM-covered aluminium (Annex I codes), which totalled €30.34 billion and 9.14 million tonnes from outside the EU (Comext DS-045409, extracted October 12, 2026).

Norway (€4.47 billion), Iceland (€2.20 billion) and Switzerland (€1.67 billion) are outside CBAM: point 1 of Annex III to Regulation (EU) 2023/956 exempts goods originating there. Together the three supplied 27.5% of extra-EU aluminium imports by value in 2025 and 29.3% by tonnage, and their metal carries no CBAM obligation.

Among the origins CBAM does reach, China is the largest by value: €3.25 billion in 2025, 10.7% of extra-EU imports, nearly all of it aluminium products, with only 12 thousand tonnes of unwrought metal (Eurostat Comext, 2025).

China is the world's largest primary aluminium producer, and detailed analysis of CBAM's impact on Chinese producers is covered in the CBAM China article.

China's national ETS was extended to aluminium smelting under a work plan of March 20, 2025, but allowances are 100% freely allocated and the average 2025 secondary-market price was CNY 70.78 (USD 9.85), per ICAP. The scheme is not recognised under Article 9, and little or no carbon price is effectively paid.

The EU imported €2.84 billion of CBAM-covered aluminium from Türkiye in 2025, 684 thousand tonnes (Eurostat Comext, 2025). Türkiye's Emissions Trading System Regulation was published on August 27, 2026, and the 2026 to 2027 pilot allocates 100% of allowances for free, so no carbon price is effectively paid and no Article 9 reduction accrues.

The UAE (EGA) and Bahrain (Alba) supplied 454 and 476 thousand tonnes of unwrought aluminium (CN 7601) in 2025, 7.2% and 7.5% of extra-EU imports by quantity (Eurostat Comext, 2025). Their metal faces CBAM on its direct emissions, with a default value of 1.870 tCO₂e per tonne each.


What Happens to Exporters Who Use Default Values

Aluminium exporters relying on default embedded emissions data face a growing cost penalty that follows a defined trajectory under Regulation (EU) 2025/2083 and IR 2025/2621.

How the Default Mark-Up Escalates

The default mark-up for aluminium (as well as steel, cement, and hydrogen) increases on the following schedule.

  • 2026: 10% above the calculated base default
  • 2027: 20% above the calculated base default
  • 2028 and beyond: 30% above the calculated base default

For the UAE default of 1.870 tCO₂e per tonne, the 30% mark-up from 2028 adds 0.561 tCO₂e per tonne, which is charged in full: €46.18 per tonne at €82.32.

On default values the cost per tonne of UAE unwrought aluminium rises from €55.12 for 2026 imports to €73.44 for 2027, €94.69 for 2028 and €139.79 for 2030, at a constant €82.32 and with the CBAM factor falling to 51.5%.

The figures for 2027 onward use today's benchmark, which may be updated for goods imported from 2027. Those costs are renegotiated into lower purchase prices paid to the exporter.

Is There Any Case for Accepting Default Values?

Only where a smelter's verified direct emissions are at or above its country default plus mark-up. For unwrought aluminium the benchmark is the same on both paths (1.423 tCO₂e per tonne on the primary route, in Column A and Column B), so for primary metal made from alumina the comparison comes down largely to the emissions figure. A UAE smelter below 2.057 tCO₂e per tonne gains from verified data in 2026, and that threshold rises as the mark-up grows. Exporters should model both paths with their own data before choosing.


Frequently Asked Questions: CBAM Aluminium Exporters

Does CBAM price the electricity used in aluminium smelting?

No. CBAM aluminium covers only direct emissions and perfluorocarbons. Indirect emissions from electricity consumption are excluded because aluminium is listed in Annex II of Regulation (EU) 2023/956. EU aluminium producers receive state aid compensation for indirect carbon costs under the ETS Directive, and including indirect CBAM costs while maintaining that compensation would create an asymmetry. A technical study published by DG TAXUD in June 2026 examined whether indirect-emissions coverage could be extended to further CBAM goods. As of October 12, 2026, aluminium remains in Annex II and its indirect emissions carry no CBAM obligation.

What PFCs are included in CBAM aluminium calculations?

Two perfluorocarbons are included: CF₄ (tetrafluoromethane) with a GWP of 6,630, and C₂F₆ (hexafluoroethane) with a GWP of 11,100. Both are expressed as CO₂e and added to direct CO₂ in the specific embedded emissions calculation. PFC emissions arise from anode effect events during Hall-Héroult electrolysis.

Is secondary (recycled) aluminium exempt from CBAM?

Secondary aluminium is not exempt, but its embedded emissions are far lower than those of primary metal. Recycled scrap is treated as a zero-emissions input, and re-melting produces roughly 0.05 to 0.1 tCO₂e per tonne (a rough industry figure). On default values, the Annex I rows that print the secondary route, such as Japan and South Korea, carry a default of 0.360 tCO₂e per tonne of unwrought aluminium (CN 7601) and a benchmark of 0.091, which gives €25.29 per tonne for 2026 imports at the official Q3 2026 price of €82.32. A re-melter with lower verified emissions is charged on its own figure.

Are Norwegian aluminium exporters affected by CBAM?

No. Goods originating in Norway are exempt from CBAM under point 1 of Annex III to Regulation (EU) 2023/956, and Norwegian smelters are covered by the EU ETS through the EEA Agreement. Norway was the largest origin of EU aluminium imports in 2025, with €4.47 billion and 1.55 million tonnes of CBAM-covered aluminium, 14.7% of extra-EU imports by value (Eurostat Comext DS-045409, extracted October 12, 2026), and none of it carries a CBAM obligation.

What is the CBAM default value for primary aluminium?

The default value for unwrought aluminium (CN 7601) is set per country in Annex I to IR (EU) 2025/2621, as replaced by IR (EU) 2026/1740: 1.870 tCO₂e per tonne for the UAE, Bahrain and India, 1.700 for Türkiye, 3.000 for China and 2.203 for origins without a row of their own, all on the primary route. A 10% mark-up applies in 2026, which makes the UAE figure 2.057 tCO₂e per tonne; the mark-up rises to 20% in 2027 and 30% from 2028. The CBAM default values for exporters page covers the full default calculation methodology and mark-up schedule.

Does China's ETS give Chinese aluminium exporters an Article 9 deduction?

Not currently. China's national ETS was extended to aluminium smelting under a work plan of March 20, 2025, but allowances are 100% freely allocated on an output-based method, and the average 2025 secondary-market price was CNY 70.78 (USD 9.85), per ICAP. Article 9 of Regulation (EU) 2023/956 allows a reduction only for a carbon price effectively paid, with rebates and other compensation taken into account. The Commission published a draft Implementing Regulation on carbon prices paid in third countries on 13 May 2026; the consultation closed 10 June 2026, and as of October 12, 2026 the regulation had not been adopted and no country's carbon price had been recognised.


Supplementary: CBAM Aluminium vs CBAM Importers

How Does CBAM Affect EU Importers of Aluminium?

EU importers of CBAM aluminium bear the legal obligation, including authorization as a CBAM declarant, certificate purchase, and annual declaration by September 30, 2027 for calendar year 2026. The CBAM aluminium importers guide covers the full importer compliance chain.

What CN Codes Does CBAM Aluminium Cover?

CBAM aluminium covers CN codes in Chapter 76, including 7601 (unwrought aluminium, both not alloyed and alloys), 7603 (aluminium powders and flakes), 7604 (bars, rods, profiles), 7605 (wire), 7606 (plates, sheets, strip exceeding 0.2 mm), 7607 (foil up to 0.2 mm), 7608 (tubes and pipes), 7609 (fittings), 7610 (structures and parts), 7611 to 7613 (reservoirs, casks and containers), 7614 (stranded wire and cables), and 7616 (other articles). Waste and scrap (7602) are not on the list, and scrap used as an input is zero-rated.

How Does CBAM Aluminium Compare to CBAM Steel?

Both aluminium and steel are Annex II goods: only direct emissions are priced, not indirect electricity. Steel covers CO₂ only; aluminium adds PFCs. The key operational difference is that aluminium smelting is far more electricity-intensive than steelmaking, making the indirect exclusion proportionally more significant for aluminium. For steel producers, the electricity exclusion matters less because process emissions from coke combustion dominate the direct emission total.


Data sources: Regulation (EU) 2023/956 · Regulation (EU) 2025/2083 (Omnibus) · IR 2025/2621 · EU ETS data via EEX. Not legal advice.