
EAF scrap steel has the lowest CBAM benchmarks of the carbon steel routes: 0.072 tCO₂e per tonne for hot-rolled flat products (CN 7208) on the scrap/EAF route, against 1.370 tCO₂e per tonne on the blast furnace route, a ratio of 19 to 1. The benchmark is a deduction and not a cost, so the low figure does not mean a low certificate bill.
What an EU importer pays depends on the emissions it declares. On default values, most origins, Türkiye included, are assigned a blast furnace default value and the blast furnace benchmark, whatever the real mill is.
A scrap-based producer's low emissions reach the importer's bill only through verified actual values. Understanding why, and how the calculation works under Regulation (EU) 2023/956, is the central question for any importer sourcing electric arc furnace steel in 2026.
What Is the CBAM Benchmark for EAF Scrap Steel?
The CBAM default benchmark for scrap-EAF carbon steel is 0.072 tCO₂e per tonne for hot-rolled flat products (CN 7208) and 0.066 tCO₂e per tonne for semi-finished steel and bars.
Both values are printed in Column B of point 5.3 of the Annex to Implementing Regulation (EU) 2025/2620 under route (E), "Carbon Steel based on Scrap/EAF".
They cover direct emissions only, because iron and steel are listed in Annex II of Regulation (EU) 2023/956, which restricts CBAM pricing to direct emissions and excludes the electricity consumed.
The low figures reflect the electric arc furnace process when fed primarily with recycled scrap. The furnace uses electrical energy to melt the charge, produces minimal process CO₂, and avoids the carbon-intensive chemistry of iron ore reduction.
Production-stage CO₂ from electrode consumption and auxiliary fuel additions in the ladle furnace accounts for virtually all of the remaining direct emissions.
How does this benchmark compare with the other two steelmaking routes in the benchmark table? The three route values for CN 7208, the 2026 deduction each produces and the value of that deduction at the official Q3 2026 certificate price of €82.32 per tonne CO₂e are shown in the table below.
| Production Route | Column B Benchmark, CN 7208 (tCO₂e/t steel) | 2026 Deduction (benchmark × 0.975) | Value of the Deduction @ €82.32/tCO₂e | Ratio vs. Scrap-EAF |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| BF-BOF (blast furnace), route (C) | 1.370 | 1.33575 | €109.96/t | 19.0× |
| DRI-EAF (gas-based DRI), route (D) | 0.481 | 0.46898 | €38.61/t | 6.7× |
| Scrap-EAF (recycled scrap), route (E) | 0.072 | 0.07020 | €5.78/t | 1.0× (baseline) |
Source: Implementing Regulation (EU) 2025/2620, Annex, point 5.3, Column B. The deduction is the benchmark × the 2026 CBAM factor of 97.5% × the cross-sectoral correction factor of 100%, and it is subtracted from the embedded emissions declared.
The 19 to 1 ratio is the BF-BOF benchmark (1.370) divided by the scrap-EAF benchmark (0.072), which yields 19.03. It is a ratio of deductions, not of certificate costs. The EU CBAM guide explains the broader certificate mechanism and how embedded emissions connect to certificate surrender obligations.
Why Does Scrap-Based Production Have Such Low Embedded Emissions?
Scrap-based EAF production achieves its low emission intensity because the carbon-intensive step of reducing iron ore to metallic iron has already been performed in a prior production cycle.
Iron ore reduction in a blast furnace requires approximately 700–800 kg of metallurgical coke per tonne of pig iron produced, and the combustion of that coke generates CO₂ at a rate of approximately 1.5 to 2.0 tCO₂ per tonne of crude steel.
When scrap steel enters an electric arc furnace, that reduction step is absent: the metallic iron is already there, locked in the recycled material.
The electric arc furnace melts its charge using three-phase electrical arcs, typically reaching temperatures above 1,600 degrees Celsius within 30 to 45 minutes per heat.
Direct CO₂ emissions arise from three small sources: graphite electrode consumption (approximately 1.5 to 2.0 kg of carbon per tonne of liquid steel), auxiliary natural gas burners used in the early melt phase (optional and increasingly replaced), and ladle furnace heating.
The CBAM acts print no emission factor for them. The official yardsticks are the scrap/EAF default benchmarks, 0.066 tCO₂e per tonne for semi-finished steel and 0.072 for hot-rolled flat products, and this site uses those two values wherever it illustrates scrap-EAF direct emissions.
What determines whether an imported steel product is treated as scrap-EAF under CBAM? On default values, the country of origin does.
Point 5.1 of the Annex to IR (EU) 2025/2620 requires the production route indicated in the country's row of Annex I to IR (EU) 2025/2621, as replaced by IR (EU) 2026/1740, and the importer does not choose it.
Only six country tables indicate scrap/EAF routes: Azerbaijan, Myanmar, North Macedonia, the Philippines, Thailand and Uzbekistan. On actual values, the operator reports the production route of the installation in its emissions report, and the verifier checks it.
For a deeper look at how embedded emissions flow from crude steel through to flat-rolled and long products, the CBAM steel sector guide covers the precursor chain and the mass-balance allocation rules that govern downstream products such as hot-rolled coil and structural sections.
How the CBAM Certificate Cost Is Calculated for EAF Imports
The CBAM certificate cost calculation for EAF scrap steel imports follows a four-step process. The steps combine Articles 7 and 31 of Regulation (EU) 2023/956, as amended by Regulation (EU) 2025/2083, with the Annex to IR (EU) 2025/2620.
The four calculation steps, shown for 10,000 tonnes of steel bars (CN 7213) from a Turkish EAF mill imported in Q3 2026 on default values, are as follows:
- Determine the embedded emissions value. Use the verified actual emissions from the exporting installation if the producer has provided a verified emissions report. If no verified data is available, use the default value in Annex I to IR (EU) 2025/2621, as replaced by IR (EU) 2026/1740. For Türkiye and CN 7213 that is 2.310 tCO₂e/t with route (C), plus a 10% mark-up in 2026 (rising to 20% in 2027 and 30% from 2028 onward): 2.541 tCO₂e/t. The Türkiye table has no scrap-EAF default.
- Deduct the free allocation adjustment. The adjustment is the CBAM factor × the cross-sectoral correction factor × the benchmark for the route in the Annex I row: 0.975 × 1.00 × 1.364 = 1.3299 tCO₂e/t. That leaves 2.541 minus 1.3299 = 1.2111 certificates per tonne.
- Multiply by the imported tonnage. An importer bringing in 10,000 tonnes would calculate: 10,000 × 1.2111 = 12,111 certificates.
- Multiply by the CBAM certificate price. Certificate prices for 2026 imports are the quarterly average of EU ETS auction prices (Article 21(1a)). At the official Q3 2026 price of €82.32/tCO₂e, the obligation is 12,111 × €82.32 = €996,977.52, or €99.70 per tonne. On the same inputs the cost for 2030 imports is €189.38 per tonne, with a 30% mark-up and a CBAM factor of 51.5%, on today's benchmark, which may be updated for goods imported from 2027.
That result has nothing to do with the mill's real emissions. An EAF mill that reports verified actual values replaces the 2.541 with its own figure.
The deduction then rests on the Column A benchmarks: 0.038 for CN 7213 itself plus the free allocation embedded in the crude steel precursor, for which Column A prints 0.065 on the scrap/EAF route (CN 7207 11 14). The saving is the emissions gap priced at the certificate price, adjusted for that smaller deduction.
The detailed methodology for calculating how embedded emissions are calculated is documented separately, covering the specific equations from Implementing Regulation (EU) 2025/2547 that apply to steel products.
How EAF Scrap Steel CBAM Costs Compare Over Time
On default values, the comparison that matters is between country tables, not furnace types. The table below sets Turkish bars, which receive a blast furnace default and benchmark, beside bars from North Macedonia, one of the six origins whose table indicates scrap/EAF. Both rows are CN 7213 at a constant certificate price of €82.32/tCO₂e.
| Year | CBAM Factor | Default Mark-up | Türkiye: default 2.310, route (C), benchmark 1.364 (€/t) | North Macedonia: default 1.530, route (E), benchmark 0.066 (€/t) | North Macedonia minus Türkiye (€/t) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2026 | 97.5% | 10% | €99.70 | €133.25 | €33.55 |
| 2027 | 95% | 20% | €121.52 | €145.98 | €24.46 |
| 2028 | 90% | 30% | €146.15 | €158.84 | €12.69 |
| 2029 | 77.5% | 30% | €160.19 | €159.52 | −€0.67 |
| 2030 | 51.5% | 30% | €189.38 | €160.94 | −€28.44 |
| From 2034 | None applies | 30% | €247.21 | €163.73 | −€83.48 |
Calculated with the default values of Annex I to IR (EU) 2025/2621, as replaced by IR (EU) 2026/1740, and the Column B benchmarks of IR (EU) 2025/2620. Net cost = (default × (1 + mark-up) minus CBAM factor × benchmark) × €82.32. No cross-sectoral correction factor is set for 2031 to 2033. Benchmarks and default values may be updated for later years (recital 10 of IR (EU) 2025/2620 foresees updated benchmarks for goods imported from 2027), so the rows from 2027 onward are indicative.
The scrap/EAF origin costs more in 2026 although its default value is a third lower, because its benchmark deducts only 0.064 tCO₂e per tonne against 1.330 for route (C). The order reverses in 2029 as the deduction shrinks, and from 2034, when no deduction remains, only the default values count.
For an EAF mill in either country the lesson is the same: its real advantage, direct emissions far below any default, is priced only when it supplies verified actual values.
Certificate price alerts and the regulatory changes that matter. Get weekly updates on what happens regarding anything CBAM-related. No spam, unsubscribe anytime.
We store only your email address for these alerts. Privacy policy
EAF Scrap Steel, CBAM, and the Zero-Rating of Scrap Inputs
The Annex I entry for Chapter 72 excepts ferrous waste and scrap (heading 7204), so scrap is not a CBAM good and not a precursor.
Post-consumer and pre-consumer scrap therefore enter the EAF process with zero embedded emissions. Recital 19 of the downstream proposal COM(2025)989 describes the current position in the same terms: pre-consumer steel scrap is "assigned zero-emissions" under Regulation (EU) 2023/956.
The practical implication is direct: an EAF operator who increases the scrap share of the furnace charge from 80% to 95% reduces the direct emissions attributed to the steel produced, because the small remaining direct emission sources (electrodes, auxiliary fuel) are spread over the same output tonnage with no additional process emissions from the additional scrap content.
The emissions reduction is continuous across the full range of charge compositions, and it is captured only when verified actual values are declared.
COM(2025)989, the Commission's proposal for downstream expansion of CBAM from January 2028, would treat pre-consumer steel and aluminium scrap as a CBAM precursor, so that its emissions are counted in the goods made from it. Parliament adopted its negotiating mandate on September 15, 2026.
The first trilogue on October 20, 2026 ended without an overall agreement (press reports), with metal scrap among four issues sent to technical work, and a second is reported for November 30, 2026; the file is still a proposal. Until an amendment is adopted and applies, scrap inputs carry no embedded emissions.
Supplementary Reference: EAF Scrap Steel CBAM Compliance Questions
Is EAF steel always lower-cost under CBAM than BF-BOF steel?
No. On default values the furnace type does not enter the calculation: the default value and the route come from the country's Annex I row. Turkish bars (CN 7213) cost €99.70 per tonne for 2026 imports at €82.32/tCO₂e whether the mill is an electric arc furnace or a blast furnace. EAF scrap steel is lower-cost where the mill reports verified actual values, because its direct emissions are a fraction of a blast furnace's and every tonne of CO₂e above the deduction is charged at the full certificate price. The 19 to 1 ratio compares benchmarks, which are deductions, and says nothing about relative cost.
Does the scrap source country affect the EAF CBAM benchmark?
The scrap source country does not affect the CBAM benchmark for the finished EAF steel product. On default values the benchmark follows the country of origin of the steel and the route in that country's Annex I row. On actual values it follows the production route at the steel-producing installation. The geography of the scrap supply chain plays no part, and scrap itself (heading 7204) is not a CBAM good.
Can an EU importer use the scrap-EAF benchmark for DRI-EAF steel?
An EU importer does not choose a benchmark. On default values the route is the one indicated in the country's Annex I row, and no country table indicates the DRI/EAF route (D), so the 0.481 value for CN 7208 is not selected on that path. On actual values, the operator reports the route of the installation, the verifier checks it, and the Column A value for that route applies. A declaration built on a wrong route understates the certificates due. It can be corrected on review under Article 19 of Regulation (EU) 2023/956, and certificates not surrendered attract the Article 26(1) penalty, the EU ETS excess emissions penalty of €100 per tonne CO₂e before indexation.
Is Turkey's EAF scrap steel subject to the same CBAM benchmark as India's?
Yes on default values. The tables of both Türkiye and India indicate route (C), so billets and bars from either origin are deducted the BF/BOF benchmark of 1.364 tCO₂e per tonne. The default values differ: for billets (CN 7207 11 14) Türkiye's is 2.310 and India's is 4.270, which gives €99.70 and €277.18 per tonne for 2026 imports at €82.32/tCO₂e. On actual values, an EAF mill in either country uses its own verified emissions and the Column A benchmarks for the scrap/EAF route. Turkish EAF producers have a strong incentive to supply verified data, since the Türkiye default carries the blast furnace route.
Does EAF scrap steel face CBAM if annual import volume is below 50 tonnes?
EAF scrap steel imports are exempt where the importer's CBAM goods do not exceed the de minimis threshold of 50 tonnes of net mass in the calendar year, under Article 2a of Regulation (EU) 2023/956, inserted by Regulation (EU) 2025/2083. The 50-tonne threshold applies to the total mass of CBAM-covered goods from all sectors combined, not per CN code, and the importer declares the exemption in the customs declaration. An importer bringing in 30 tonnes of EAF steel bars (CN 7213) and 25 tonnes of BF-BOF steel sheet (CN 7208) in the same calendar year exceeds the threshold and becomes subject to full CBAM obligations for all covered imports.
Should importers choose EAF scrap steel specifically to reduce CBAM costs?
Sourcing from an EAF scrap-based producer reduces CBAM certificate costs only if that producer supplies verified actual emissions. On default values the importer pays the country default with its mark-up whatever the furnace: €99.70 per tonne for Turkish bars in 2026 at €82.32/tCO₂e. The CBAM obligation is one factor in a sourcing decision alongside price, specification, lead time, and supplier reliability. Its weight grows each year, and on the same default the cost reaches €189.38 per tonne for 2030 imports (on today's benchmark, which may be updated for goods imported from 2027).
For high-volume importers with multi-year supply contracts, a clause requiring the verified emissions report is therefore a material financial term. The CBAM steel calculation guide provides worked examples for different steel grades and production origins.
How does scrap-EAF CBAM compare to BF-BOF CBAM from high-carbon producers?
The contrast is sharpest between an EAF mill on verified actual values and a blast furnace producer on default values. China's steel slab default (CN 7207 12 10) under Implementing Regulation (EU) 2025/2621, as replaced by IR (EU) 2026/1740, is 3.169 tCO₂e/t. With the 2026 mark-up and the route (C) benchmark of 1.364, an EU importer pays €177.48 per tonne at €82.32/tCO₂e, rising to €281.31 per tonne for 2030 imports at the same price (on today's benchmark, which may be updated for goods imported from 2027).
An EAF mill's verified direct emissions are a fraction of that default, and its obligation is those emissions minus a deduction based on the Column A benchmarks. An EAF mill left on default values gets no such advantage: Turkish billets cost €99.70 per tonne in 2026. The BF-BOF steel and CBAM article covers the blast furnace route and its default value implications in full.
Further Resources for Steel Importers Under CBAM
The obligations for EU importers sourcing steel from any production route extend beyond certificate costs to include authorization, embedded emissions reporting, verifier engagement, and declaration submission. The four key supplementary references for steel importers are listed below.
The 4 key CBAM reference pages for steel importers cover the following topics:
- CBAM default values explains when and how default values apply, the 10% to 30% mark-up schedule by year, and the financial case for obtaining verified actual emissions data from exporters
- BF-BOF steel and CBAM covers the blast furnace route benchmarks, China and India default exposures, and the cost trajectory through 2034
- CBAM steel calculation guide provides worked calculation examples for each steel CN code group with embedded emission flows from crude steel through finished products
- CBAM compliance for steel importers covers the authorization process, the September 30, 2027 first declaration deadline, verifier requirements, and the quarterly certificate holding obligation that applies from 2027 (at least 50% of embedded emissions imported since the start of the year)