CBAM Article 9: Carbon Price Deduction: Who Qualifies and How to Claim It

Article 9 lets EU importers cut CBAM certificates for a carbon price paid abroad.

Page contents
A carbon price charged to a producer abroad, as a tax or ETS allowances, loses rebates, free allowances and compensation; the price effectively paid, certified by an independent person, means fewer CBAM certificates at the same price.

Article 9 of Regulation (EU) 2023/956 gives EU importers one concrete way to reduce the number of CBAM certificates they must surrender: by deducting a carbon price already paid in the country of origin.

The rules are now law: Commission Implementing Regulation (EU) 2026/2498 of November 5, 2026, published in the Official Journal on November 16, 2026, applies from January 1, 2026.

Its Annex II lists 36 carbon price mechanisms in 24 jurisdictions, among them South Korea's K-ETS, China's national ETS, India's CCTS, the UK ETS and the Türkiye ETS. A listed scheme is not an automatic deduction: only the price effectively paid, after free allocation and other rebates, counts, and an independent person must certify it.

Understanding what the regulation requires, where each major scheme stands, and how to calculate and document the deduction correctly is the operational task this article covers in full.


What the CBAM Carbon Price Deduction Actually Does

The Article 9 carbon price deduction reduces the number of CBAM certificates an authorized declarant must surrender, not the price of each certificate. This distinction carries significant practical consequences for how importers calculate their net liability.

For 2026 emissions, CBAM certificates are priced at the quarterly average of EU ETS auction closing prices under Article 21(1a): €75.36 for Q1, €75.28 for Q2, and €82.32 for Q3 2026, the last published on October 5, 2026. Weekly prices under Article 21(1) apply from 2027.

If a non-EU producer has paid a legally binding carbon price equivalent to €20 per tonne CO₂ for the embedded emissions of the exported goods, the importer does not pay the certificate price minus €20. Instead, the importer surrenders fewer certificates, with the reduction calculated proportionally.

Article 7 of IR (EU) 2026/2498 sets the formula: Reduction in certificates = (Effective carbon price in € per tonne of good) / (Yearly reference price of CBAM certificates in €/tCO₂e) × (Quantity of the good in tonnes).

The effective carbon price per tonne of good is the price effectively paid on the good's embedded emissions, as stated in the certification report.

In the example, €20 per tonne CO₂ on goods with 2 tCO₂ per tonne is €40 per tonne of good; at an illustrative reference price of €75, each tonne needs 40/75 = 0.53 fewer certificates, about 26.7% of its obligation before the free allocation adjustment.

How does this interact with the rest of the compliance cycle? The deduction is claimed at the annual CBAM declaration stage, filed via the CBAM Registry by September 30 of the year following import. For calendar year 2026 imports, the first deadline is September 30, 2027.

The EU carbon border adjustment mechanism was specifically designed to equalize the carbon cost of imported and domestically produced goods. Article 9 is the mechanism's acknowledgment that some trading partners already price carbon, and that double-charging those emissions would be economically unjust and politically counterproductive.


The Three Conditions a Carbon Pricing Scheme Must Meet

Three cumulative conditions follow from Article 9(1) of Regulation (EU) 2023/956, read with the definition of "carbon price" in Article 3(29).

The three conditions are listed below. All three must be satisfied simultaneously; partial compliance does not qualify.

  1. Legal binding force. The carbon pricing scheme must be mandated and enforced by government law. Voluntary schemes, internal corporate carbon prices, and unilaterally applied industry agreements are explicitly excluded. The scheme must constitute a legally enforceable obligation on covered installations.

  2. Coverage of the same emissions. The foreign scheme must cover the same greenhouse gases and the same production processes as CBAM covers for the relevant goods. A scheme that prices only electricity-sector emissions does not qualify for goods produced in the steel sector, because the emissions covered are different. The coverage must map directly to the embedded emissions for which the Article 9 deduction is being claimed.

  3. Rebates and compensation deducted. Article 9(1) requires any rebate or other form of compensation available in the third country to be taken into account. Article 9 of IR (EU) 2026/2498 names the forms: reduced tax rates, exempted emissions (free allowances and emissions under a baseline included), monetary refunds and other compensation. Without evidence of the amount, no deduction is allowed.

IR (EU) 2026/2498 turns these conditions into operational rules. Article 4 accepts two types of mechanism: an emissions trading system, including a baseline-and-credit system, or a carbon tax, levy or fee, fuel-based or point-source.

The mechanisms in its Annex II "shall be considered as meeting" that definition; for unlisted ones the Commission assesses and may add them.

International credits under Article 6 of the Paris Agreement count for at most 10% of the emissions covered by the mechanism (Annex I). The default carbon prices of Article 9(4), which the Commission makes available in the CBAM Registry, had not been published as of November 18, 2026.


Which Countries Qualify for the Article 9 Deduction in 2026

Annex II to IR (EU) 2026/2498 lists 36 carbon price mechanisms in 24 jurisdictions; the list is not exhaustive.

Listed are Albania, Argentina, Australia, eight Canadian provincial and federal output-based systems plus Quebec's cap-and-trade, Chile, China, Colombia, India, Indonesia, Israel, Japan (carbon tax and GX-ETS), Kazakhstan, Mexico, Montenegro, New Zealand, Serbia, Singapore, South Africa, South Korea, Taiwan, Türkiye, the UK (UK ETS and Carbon Price Support), Ukraine, and California, Oregon and Washington.

A listing settles only that the mechanism counts as a carbon price mechanism. The table, using ICAP scheme data, shows why the amount effectively paid is a separate question.

Country Carbon Pricing Scheme Legally Binding Covers CBAM Sectors Free Allocation or Rebate In Annex II to IR (EU) 2026/2498
South Korea K-ETS (Korea Emissions Trading Scheme) Yes Yes (steel, cement, other manufacturing) 100% free allocation for steel, cement, and non-ferrous metals in Phase 4 (2026 to 2030) Yes
Switzerland Swiss ETS (linked to EU ETS) Yes Yes Not relevant Outside CBAM scope (Annex III)
UK UK ETS; Carbon Price Support Yes Yes (power and industry) Part of industrial allowances allocated free Yes, both
South Africa Carbon tax (Carbon Tax Act 15 of 2019), R308 per tCO₂e from January 1, 2026 (National Treasury) Yes Fuel combustion, industrial process and fugitive emissions of entities above a capacity threshold (SARS) Tax-free allowances of 60% to 95% depending on the industry (SARS) Yes
China National ETS (CN-ETS) Yes Yes since 2025 (power, steel, cement, aluminium smelting) Allowances 100% free, intensity-based Yes
India CCTS (intensity-based baseline-and-credit) Yes, for notified sectors Partial (aluminium and cement notified; iron and steel targets not notified as of February 2026) Credits and obligations set against intensity targets Yes
Turkey TR-ETS pilot (regulation published August 27, 2026) Yes Power and energy-intensive industry 100% free allocation for 2027 emissions; 2026 is reporting only Yes; no price effectively paid yet
Russia Sakhalin regional pilot ETS, the only Russian system in ICAP's Status Report 2023; penalty of RUB 1,000 per tCO₂e above the allocated cap Regional experiment under a 2022 federal law Not assessed here Not assessed here No
Ukraine CO₂ tax; national ETS planned from 2028 Yes (tax) Not assessed here Not assessed here Yes (carbon tax)
Brazil SBCE (Law No. 15,042/2024), under development Not yet operating Scope to be set by regulation N/A No

South Korea's K-ETS is a legally binding cap-and-trade system that has operated since 2015 and covers manufacturing sectors including steel, cement, and petrochemicals. It is listed in Annex II, so it counts as a carbon price mechanism.

The amount at stake is limited: ICAP reports that sectors at risk of carbon leakage, including steel, cement, and non-ferrous metals, keep 100% free allocation in Phase 4 (2026 to 2030), and free allowances are exempted emissions that Article 9 of IR (EU) 2026/2498 requires to be deducted.

China's CN-ETS has covered steel, cement, and aluminium smelting since its 2025 expansion, in addition to power, per ICAP. Annex II lists it as an emissions trading system, with free allowances and a liability cap as its main forms of compensation.

Two features limit any deduction: allowances are allocated 100% free of charge, and the scheme is intensity-based, so a producer whose emissions stay within its free allocation has effectively paid little or nothing.

Turkey published its Emissions Trading System Regulation in the Official Gazette on August 27, 2026, under the Climate Law of July 2025. Per ICAP, the pilot phase covers 2026 and 2027 emissions: 2026 is a reporting-only year, the free allocation rate for 2027 emissions is 100%, and the first surrender deadline falls in November 2028.

Turkish steel, cement, and aluminium producers therefore pay no carbon price yet, meaning EU importers sourcing from Turkey have nothing to deduct under Article 9 and bear the full certificate obligation for those goods.


How to Calculate the Article 9 Deduction

Calculating the Article 9 carbon price deduction requires three inputs. The calculation process involves the steps described below.

The three required inputs are as follows.

  • Specific embedded emissions of the goods, expressed in tCO₂e per tonne of product, as verified under IR (EU) 2025/2546 by a verifier accredited under DR (EU) 2025/2551
  • The carbon price effectively paid, denominated in EUR or converted to EUR at the applicable exchange rate, reduced by any free allocation, state compensation, or export rebates received by the producer
  • The yearly reference price of CBAM certificates for the year of import: the average of that year's quarterly (2026) or weekly (from 2027) certificate prices, rounded to the cent and published by the Commission in the CBAM Registry (Article 7(3) of IR (EU) 2026/2498)

Step 1: Obtain Verified Proof of Carbon Price Payment

Collect documentary evidence that the carbon price was paid at the production installation level. Acceptable documentation includes ETS compliance certificates showing allowances surrendered and quantities covered, carbon tax payment receipts issued by the relevant government authority, and third-country regulator confirmations of compliance status. The documentation must be installation-specific, not company-level or sector-level.

The Article 9 deduction applies to the carbon price "effectively paid." This means the gross price must be reduced by any free allowances the installation received at no cost, any state subsidies compensating for the carbon cost, and any export rebates returned by the government.

For South Korean K-ETS participants in the steel sector, ICAP reports 100% free allocation in Phase 4 (2026 to 2030), so the price effectively paid may be close to zero.

Under Article 9(2) and IR (EU) 2026/2498, the operator writes a carbon price report in English on the Commission's template (Article 8), and an independent person certifies it with reasonable assurance at a materiality level of 5% (Articles 12 and 18).

For the 2026 and 2027 reporting periods, a verifier accredited under DR (EU) 2025/2551 may opt into that role through the CBAM Registry; the role lapses on September 30, 2028 unless the verifier gains the new accreditation (Article 11). From February 1, 2027, certification reports are issued in the CBAM Registry (Article 19).

Step 2: Convert the Foreign Carbon Price to EUR

The foreign carbon price must be expressed in EUR for the deduction calculation. Article 6 of IR (EU) 2026/2498 requires the yearly average exchange rate for the reporting year, as published by the Commission from European Central Bank or Eurostat rates.

Importers should document the rate used, apply it consistently across the declaration year, and keep the records until the end of the fourth year after the year in which the CBAM declaration has been or should have been submitted, as Article 9(3) requires.

Step 3: Apply the Deduction Formula

Using the verified embedded emissions, the effective foreign carbon price in EUR, and the CBAM certificate price, calculate the certificate reduction as follows.

Illustrative calculation with assumed figures for South Korean steel:

  • Imported: 1,000 tonnes of BF-BOF steel from a K-ETS covered installation
  • Specific embedded emissions: 2.0 tCO₂/t (a hypothetical actual value assumed for this illustration, not a default value or a benchmark)
  • Total embedded emissions: 2,000 tCO₂
  • Assumed effective carbon price paid (net of free allocation): €18/tCO₂ (converted from KRW at the yearly average rate)
  • Yearly reference price: €82.32/tCO₂e, the official Q3 2026 price standing in for the 2026 average, which is set once the Q4 price is published on January 4, 2027
  • Certificate reduction: (18/82.32) × 2,000 = 437 certificates
  • Certificates before the free allocation adjustment and the deduction: 2,000
  • Certificates after the deduction alone: 1,563

The example leaves out the free allocation adjustment. The 2026 obligation is not a flat 2.5% of embedded emissions: under Implementing Regulation (EU) 2025/2620 the free allocation adjustment is built on the CBAM benchmark, so emissions above the benchmark are charged in full.

The carbon price term is subtracted together with that adjustment, and the result cannot fall below zero.

Step 4: Document and Submit the Deduction in the Annual Declaration

The annual CBAM declaration, submitted via the CBAM Registry by September 30, 2027 for calendar year 2026 imports, must include under Article 6: the carbon price claimed per tonne of CO₂e, the specific installation and goods to which it applies, and supporting documentation.

The competent authority retains the right to inspect all Article 9 deduction claims, and the record-keeping obligation runs to the end of the fourth year after the year in which the declaration has been or should have been submitted (Article 9(3)).

The role of CBAM certificates is central here: the deduction reduces the certificate count to surrender, but each certificate still corresponds to one tonne CO₂e. The mathematics of the deduction formula reflect this direct tonne-for-tonne logic.


The CBAM newsletter

Certificate price alerts and the regulatory changes that matter. Get weekly updates on what happens regarding anything CBAM-related. No spam, unsubscribe anytime.

We store only your email address for these alerts. Privacy policy

China's ETS: Listed, but Little Price Is Effectively Paid

China's national ETS is listed in Annex II to IR (EU) 2026/2498, so it counts as a carbon price mechanism for Article 9. Two features still stand between Chinese producers and a usable deduction: free allocation and intensity-based design.

Sector coverage is no longer the first obstacle. The CN-ETS launched in 2021 with the power sector only, and the Ministry of Ecology and Environment's work plan of March 20, 2025 extended it to steel, cement, and aluminium smelting; ICAP counts more than 3,300 covered companies. Fertilizer production is not covered.

The obstacle is free allocation: allowances are 100% freely allocated, and for the 2024 compliance year entities in the three new sectors received allowances equal to their verified emissions. Article 9(1) requires such compensation to be taken into account, so little or no price is effectively paid.

The second feature is the intensity-versus-absolute-cap structural mismatch. The CN-ETS allocates allowances on an output and intensity basis, not against an absolute emission cap. A plant that improves its intensity while increasing total output can expand production with no additional allowance cost.

CBAM measures absolute embedded emissions per tonne of product. Article 9 of IR (EU) 2026/2498 counts free allowances among the exempted emissions to be deducted, so an installation whose emissions stay within its free allocation has little or no price effectively paid.

China's August 2025 policy roadmap sets out a transition from an intensity-based cap to an absolute cap, and auctioning is to be introduced without a timeline, per ICAP.

Until Chinese steel producers pay a price that free allocation does not offset, the deductible amount stays small: ICAP reports an average 2025 secondary market price of CNY 70.78 (about USD 9.85).

The financial consequence grows over time. The 2026 obligation is not a flat 2.5% of embedded emissions: under Implementing Regulation (EU) 2025/2620 the free allocation adjustment is built on the CBAM benchmark, so emissions above the benchmark are charged in full.

As that adjustment shrinks each year until free allocation ends in 2034, a small or zero Article 9 deduction weighs more heavily on EU importers sourcing Chinese-origin goods.


Contextual Border: How Article 9 Fits into the Full CBAM Compliance Cycle

The Article 9 carbon price deduction is one of three provisions that shape an authorized declarant's final position: two adjustments reduce the number of certificates to surrender, and the repurchase right returns money for certificates bought in excess without changing the surrender obligation. Understanding how they interact prevents both over- and under-compliance.

The three provisions are listed below.

  1. SEFA adjustment (free allocation reduction). The specific embedded free allocation is the CBAM factor (97.5% for 2026) multiplied by the cross-sectoral correction factor and the CBAM benchmark, and it is subtracted from specific embedded emissions. The 2026 obligation is not a flat 2.5% of embedded emissions: under Implementing Regulation (EU) 2025/2620 the free allocation adjustment is built on the CBAM benchmark, so emissions above the benchmark are charged in full.

  2. Article 9 deduction (foreign carbon price). The carbon price term is subtracted together with the SEFA adjustment, based on the foreign carbon price effectively paid, and the result cannot fall below zero.

  3. Repurchase provision (excess certificates). Under Article 23 as amended, a declarant can ask by October 31 of the surrender year for excess certificates to be repurchased at the price paid. Article 23(2) limits the number to "the total number of CBAM certificates that the authorised CBAM declarant had an obligation to purchase pursuant to Article 22(2) during the calendar year of the purchase". This is a risk management tool, not an emissions-based adjustment.

The CBAM regulation details are fully set out in the CBAM regulation, including the interaction between these three adjustment mechanisms and the implementing regulations that govern each.


Does the Article 9 Deduction Apply to Default Values?

Only in a limited form. Under Article 9(4), where embedded emissions are determined on the basis of default values, a reduction may be claimed only by reference to default carbon prices, which the Commission makes available in the CBAM Registry. Article 7(2) of IR (EU) 2026/2498 gives the formula: default carbon price × declared embedded emissions ÷ yearly reference price × quantity. The Commission says the default carbon prices will be published in time for the first declarations; none had been published as of November 18, 2026.

To claim a reduction under Article 9(1) for the price an installation effectively paid, the importer must use verified actual emissions data, not defaults. This creates a link between the investment in third-party verification and the financial benefit of the deduction. An importer who uses defaults cannot claim the price its supplier actually paid for that declaration period.

Does the K-ETS Qualify for All CBAM Sectors?

The K-ETS is listed in Annex II to IR (EU) 2026/2498 as an emissions trading system, without any sector limitation. ICAP reports that it covers 813 entities in the power, industrial, buildings, waste, transport, domestic aviation, and maritime sectors (2025 compliance year) and covered 77.75% of Korea's greenhouse gas emissions in 2023. Steel producers, cement manufacturers, and other industrial installations are inside the scheme, so the coverage condition is met in principle, but leakage-exposed sectors keep 100% free allocation in Phase 4.

EU importers sourcing from South Korea across steel, cement, and aluminium sectors should review whether their specific supply installations are enrolled in K-ETS and obtain installation-level compliance records before claiming the deduction. Coverage at the sector level does not automatically mean coverage at every installation.


What If a Scheme Is Not Listed in Annex II?

The list is not exhaustive. Under Article 4(3) of IR (EU) 2026/2498, the Commission assesses a mechanism that is not listed and may add it through a revision of the regulation, which is due in 2027 at the latest; the independent person can also assess unlisted mechanisms, including sub-national and new ones (recital 7). The evidence, certification and formula rules are set out in the CBAM carbon price deduction guide.

Importers with South Korean suppliers should ask now whether each supplying installation will produce a carbon price report for 2026, and who will certify it. The first declaration, due September 30, 2027, is where the deduction is claimed.

For more detail on how the CBAM South Korea compliance picture unfolds, including K-ETS price levels and installation-level verification requirements, the country-specific guidance covers those operational specifics.


Is the Article 9 Deduction Available for Electricity Imports?

The Article 9 deduction applies to CBAM goods across all six covered sectors: iron and steel, cement, aluminium, fertilizers, electricity, and hydrogen. For electricity imports, the embedded emissions are the CO₂ intensity of the electricity generated, and the carbon price paid at the generation installation is the deductible amount.

Electricity imports into the EU traverse physical interconnectors and are subject to separate calculation rules under Article 7 of Regulation (EU) 2023/956. For the Article 9 deduction to apply to electricity, the electricity generator must operate under a legally binding carbon price scheme covering power generation, the price must be effectively paid at the generator level, and no export rebate applies. These conditions are easier to assess for electricity from the UK (where the UK ETS covers power generation directly) than from countries with no generation-sector carbon pricing.

Does South Africa's Carbon Tax Qualify Under Article 9?

South Africa's carbon tax, established under the Carbon Tax Act 15 of 2019, has applied since June 1, 2019. It is charged on the CO₂ equivalent of emissions from fuel combustion, industrial processes and fugitive sources, on entities above a capacity threshold (South African Revenue Service). The headline rate rose to R308 per tonne CO₂e on January 1, 2026 (National Treasury, 2026 Budget Review).

Annex II to IR (EU) 2026/2498 lists the South African carbon tax as a point-source carbon tax, so it counts as a carbon price mechanism.

The open question is how much of that price is "effectively paid". Tax-free allowances range from 60% to 95% depending on the industry (SARS), and the basic allowance stays at 60% until 2030, so the net rate per tonne is far below the headline rate. Article 9(1) requires such rebates and compensation to be taken into account, so only the net rate, after allowances, could count for Article 9 purposes. CBAM China and how embedded emissions are calculated provide comparative context for how coverage mapping decisions affect deduction eligibility across different country scenarios.


Frequently Asked Questions on CBAM Article 9

What is the CBAM Article 9 carbon price deduction?

The Article 9 carbon price deduction is a provision in Regulation (EU) 2023/956 that allows authorized EU importers to reduce the number of CBAM certificates they must surrender when the production installation in the country of origin has paid a legally binding carbon price on the embedded emissions of the exported goods. The deduction is proportional to the foreign carbon price relative to the CBAM certificate price and the verified embedded emissions.

Which countries qualify for the Article 9 CBAM deduction in 2026?

Annex II to Implementing Regulation (EU) 2026/2498, which applies from January 1, 2026, lists 36 carbon price mechanisms in 24 jurisdictions, including South Korea's K-ETS, China's national ETS, India's CCTS, the UK ETS and the Türkiye ETS. The list is not exhaustive. A listing does not guarantee a deduction: only the price effectively paid after free allocation and other rebates counts, certified by an independent person. Switzerland, Norway, Iceland, and Liechtenstein are outside CBAM scope through Annex III.

Does China's ETS qualify for the CBAM Article 9 deduction?

It is listed in Annex II to Implementing Regulation (EU) 2026/2498, so it counts as a carbon price mechanism. China's national ETS has covered steel, cement, and aluminium smelting since its 2025 expansion, in addition to power, but allowances are allocated free of charge on an intensity basis, and free allowances must be deducted, so little or no carbon price is effectively paid.

Can importers claim the Article 9 deduction using default emission values?

Not for the price a supplier actually paid. Article 9(1) applies where embedded emissions are determined on the basis of actual emissions, verified under IR (EU) 2025/2546 by a verifier accredited under DR (EU) 2025/2551. Where default values from IR (EU) 2025/2621 are used, Article 9(4) allows a reduction only by reference to default carbon prices, which the Commission makes available in the CBAM Registry; Article 7(2) of IR (EU) 2026/2498 gives the formula. None had been published as of November 18, 2026.

How is the Article 9 deduction calculated?

Under Article 7 of Implementing Regulation (EU) 2026/2498, the reduction in certificates equals the effective carbon price in EUR per tonne of good, as certified, divided by the yearly reference price of CBAM certificates, multiplied by the quantity of the good. The yearly reference price is the average of the year's certificate prices, published by the Commission in the CBAM Registry. The carbon price term is subtracted together with the free allocation adjustment under IR (EU) 2025/2620.

Is the Article 9 deduction the same as a carbon price exemption?

No. The Article 9 deduction reduces the number of CBAM certificates surrendered proportionally to the foreign carbon price relative to the EU ETS price. A full exemption would apply if the foreign carbon price equals the EU ETS price, making the certificate obligation zero. A partial deduction applies when the foreign carbon price is lower than the EU ETS price, which is the case for every third-country scheme discussed on this page. Full exemption occurs only when the origin country is listed in Annex III (Iceland, Liechtenstein, Norway, Switzerland), where no CBAM obligation applies at all.


Data sources: Regulation (EU) 2023/956 · Regulation (EU) 2025/2083 (Omnibus) · IR 2025/2621 · EU ETS data via EEX. Not legal advice.