CBAM Aluminium and Indirect Emissions: Why 80% of the Carbon Footprint Isn't Priced Yet

Indirect emissions cover 80% of aluminium's carbon footprint yet CBAM prices only direct output.

Page contents
An aluminium electrolysis cell fed with electricity from a power plant. CO2 from the anodes and PFCs from anode effects are counted; the emissions of generating the electricity are indirect and not counted.

CBAM aluminium indirect emissions represent the largest unpriced carbon gap in the entire Carbon Border Adjustment Mechanism: a Chinese primary aluminium smelter powered by coal-fired electricity emits roughly 12–16 tCO₂e per tonne in total, yet CBAM counts only its direct emissions, roughly 1.5 tCO₂/t for a modern smelter (a rough intensity, not a default value).

The 80% of the carbon footprint locked inside electricity consumption sits entirely outside the pricing perimeter. Understanding why this gap exists, what it means for EU importers, and when it is likely to close is essential for any business that buys or sells aluminium in the EU market.

The short answer is structural: aluminium is listed in Annex II of Regulation (EU) 2023/956, which restricts CBAM pricing to direct emissions only.

The longer answer involves a deliberate policy trade-off that connects EU state aid rules, electricity market distortions, and an explicit Commission commitment to revisit indirect coverage in a future review. This article unpacks each layer.


What CBAM Actually Prices for Aluminium in 2026

Under Regulation (EU) 2023/956, CBAM prices only the direct emissions from aluminium production: CO₂ from carbon anode consumption and perfluorocarbons (PFCs) from the Hall-Héroult electrolysis process.

Indirect emissions from electricity consumed during smelting are excluded. This scope restriction applies to all 14 aluminium entries in Annex I, including unwrought aluminium (7601), plates and sheets (7606), wire (7605), and fabricated articles (7616).

The direct emissions of a modern primary smelter run to approximately 1.5 tCO₂e per tonne (a rough intensity, not a default value), but an importer without verified data is charged on the country default.

Unwrought aluminium from China (CN 7601) carries a default of 3.000 tCO₂e per tonne, direct emissions only, or 3.300 with the 10% mark-up for 2026. The free allocation adjustment is the CBAM factor of 97.5% × the benchmark of 1.423 = 1.387425, which leaves 1.912575 certificates per tonne.

At the official Q3 2026 certificate price of €82.32, published October 5, 2026, that is €157.44 per tonne.

For 2030 imports the same default costs €260.72 per tonne at the same price, with a 30% mark-up and a CBAM factor of 51.5%, on today's benchmark, which may be updated for goods imported from 2027 (recital 10 of IR (EU) 2025/2620).

The CBAM factor is the share of free allocation retained (Article 10a(1a) of Directive 2003/87/EC).

Two greenhouse gases fall within the direct emissions scope. The first is CO₂, released as the carbon anodes oxidize during electrolysis.

The second is perfluorocarbons, specifically CF₄ with a global warming potential of 6,630 and C₂F₆ with a GWP of 11,100. PFC emissions occur during "anode effect" events when alumina feed concentration drops too low in the reduction cell.

Modern smelters in Norway and Iceland minimize this through tight process control; legacy facilities in China, Russia, and certain Gulf Cooperation Council countries still generate significant PFC output. For EU importers, this means the declared direct emissions for Chinese primary aluminium can differ substantially from those of Icelandic primary aluminium, even before electricity is considered.

For a complete grounding in how the mechanism works across all sectors, the EU CBAM guide provides the full regulatory framework and obligation chain for authorized declarants.


Why Indirect Emissions Are Excluded: The Annex II Rule

Aluminium's exclusion from indirect emission pricing is not an oversight. It is a deliberate consequence of Annex II of Regulation (EU) 2023/956, which lists goods whose CBAM obligation covers direct emissions only.

Steel, aluminium, and hydrogen all appear on Annex II for the same underlying reason: EU domestic producers in these sectors receive state aid compensation for their indirect carbon costs under Article 10a(6) of the EU ETS Directive.

The logic runs as follows. EU aluminium smelters pay an implicit carbon cost through their electricity bills because EU power generators pass through EU ETS compliance costs in the electricity price. To avoid harming the international competitiveness of EU smelters, member states are permitted to compensate them for a portion of those indirect costs.

If CBAM then added an indirect emissions charge on imported aluminium while EU producers continued receiving compensation, the mechanism would create an asymmetric double-counting. The Commission chose consistency over comprehensiveness: no indirect CBAM for a sector that receives indirect ETS compensation domestically.

Recital 65 of Regulation (EU) 2023/956 asks the Commission to collect the information needed to extend the scope to the indirect emissions of Annex II goods "as soon as possible". As of October 12, 2026 aluminium is still listed in Annex II, so only its direct emissions are priced.

The Article 30 review report of December 16, 2025 (COM(2025)783) examined five technical solutions for covering indirect emissions and concluded that further analysis is needed. It points to a review at the end of 2027 for possible proposals on the treatment of indirect emissions.

The full calculation methodology for what does fall within scope, including how precursor emissions are allocated across downstream aluminium goods, is explained in the guide on how embedded emissions are calculated.


The Carbon Gap in Numbers: Direct vs. Total Footprint

The table below compares direct and total lifecycle emissions for primary aluminium across four representative electricity grids, using a standard smelting electricity intensity of 15 MWh per tonne.

Production Location Grid Carbon Intensity Direct CO₂e (tCO₂e/t) Electricity-Derived CO₂ (tCO₂e/t) Total CO₂e (tCO₂e/t) CBAM Prices
Norway / Iceland (hydro) ~0.01 tCO₂/MWh ~1.5 ~0.15 ~1.65 None: exempt origins (Annex III, point 1)
UAE / Bahrain (natural gas) ~0.5–0.6 tCO₂/MWh ~1.5 ~7.5–9.0 ~9.0–10.5 ~14–17%
India (coal-heavy grid) ~0.7 tCO₂/MWh ~1.5 ~10.5 ~12.0 ~12.5%
China (coal-heavy grid) ~0.7–0.8 tCO₂/MWh ~1.5 ~10.5–12.0 ~12.0–13.5 ~11–12.5%

For a Chinese primary aluminium smelter operating on a coal-heavy grid, CBAM certificates in 2026 cover roughly 11–12.5% of the actual carbon footprint. Norwegian and Icelandic smelters are exempt origins under Annex III, point 1, so CBAM prices none of their footprint. That divergence is the structural competitive distortion the Annex II restriction creates.

The per-tonne value of the unpriced emissions is striking. An importer of Chinese unwrought aluminium on default values pays €157.44 per tonne in 2026 at the official Q3 2026 certificate price of €82.32, all of it for direct emissions.

None of the 10.5 to 12.0 tCO₂e per tonne of electricity-derived emissions shown in the table is charged; those are rough figures built on an assumed 15 MWh per tonne and rough grid intensities, not default values, so they are not priced here.


What EU Importers of Aluminium Need to Do in 2026

Under the definitive phase, which began January 1, 2026, EU importers of aluminium goods above the 50-tonne threshold need authorized declarant status. An importer that applied by March 31, 2026 may continue importing provisionally until the competent authority decides (Article 17(7a)).

Certificate purchases begin on February 1, 2027, and the first CBAM declaration covering calendar year 2026 is due September 30, 2027. The declaration reports the embedded direct emissions of all imported aluminium goods, on default values or on verified actual values, once the importer exceeds the 50-tonne annual de minimis threshold.

Four practical obligations define the 2026 compliance posture for aluminium importers.

The four obligations are listed below.

  1. Obtain authorized declarant status from the competent authority in your member state; the March 31, 2026 application deadline for provisional importing has passed.
  2. Request verified emissions data from each non-EU aluminium supplier, covering CO₂ from anode consumption and PFC emissions from anode effect events.
  3. Decide whether to use actual verified emissions or CBAM default values, noting that the 2026 default mark-up for aluminium is +10% above the calculated default under Implementing Regulation (EU) 2025/2621.
  4. Begin building the documentation trail for the September 30, 2027 declaration, including verified reports for each installation that produced the imported goods.

Importers sourcing from Norway, Iceland, or Switzerland face zero CBAM obligation because goods originating there are outside CBAM under Annex III, point 1 of the Regulation (Article 2(4)), which lists Iceland, Liechtenstein, Norway and Switzerland and the territories Büsingen, Heligoland, Livigno, Ceuta and Melilla.

Exempt origins supplied 29% of extra-EU imports of CBAM-covered aluminium by quantity in 2025, led by Norway with 1.55 million tonnes and Iceland with 821 thousand tonnes (Eurostat Comext DS-045409, extracted October 12, 2026).

The CBAM aluminium sector guide covers the full CN code list, the precursor allocation rules for downstream fabricated products, and country-by-country exposure across the major suppliers.


The CBAM newsletter

Certificate price alerts and the regulatory changes that matter. Get weekly updates on what happens regarding anything CBAM-related. No spam, unsubscribe anytime.

We store only your email address for these alerts. Privacy policy

The Contextual Border: When Might Indirect Emissions Be Priced?

The Commission's path to including indirect emissions in CBAM aluminium pricing runs through two obstacles: the state aid interaction problem and the political appetite for expanding compliance burdens on EU downstream manufacturers.

The state aid interaction is the primary technical barrier. Article 10a(6) compensation paid to EU aluminium smelters for indirect ETS costs cannot simply coexist with a CBAM indirect charge on competing imports without triggering WTO non-discrimination concerns.

Resolving this requires either discontinuing the compensation (which EU producers oppose) or redesigning the CBAM indirect methodology to account for domestic compensation levels. Neither path is straightforward.

The downstream exposure problem compounds the challenge. The proposed downstream extension under COM(2025)989 would add downstream steel and aluminium goods from January 1, 2028: about 180 in the Commission proposal, about 200 eight-digit codes added in the Council's general approach (the count of added codes reported by Mayer Brown) and about 457 (a trade-press estimate) in the mandate Parliament adopted on September 15, 2026.

The first trilogue on October 20, 2026 ended without an overall agreement (press reports), with an aluminium de minimis threshold among four issues sent to technical work; a second is reported for November 30, 2026, and the file is still a proposal.

Adding an indirect emissions layer on top of a downstream expansion simultaneously would increase the compliance burden significantly, particularly for EU automotive and packaging importers.

Is There Any Precedent for Pricing Indirect Emissions Under CBAM?

Cement and fertilizers establish that precedent exists. Both sectors include indirect emissions in their CBAM scope, and neither is listed in Annex II. The reason is symmetrical: EU cement and fertilizer producers do not receive Article 10a(6) compensation for indirect ETS costs, so including indirect costs in CBAM creates no domestic asymmetry. If the Commission phased out aluminium indirect compensation under the ETS, the technical barrier to extending CBAM indirect coverage would dissolve. As of October 12, 2026 aluminium remains in Annex II, and the Commission's review report COM(2025)783 points to a review at the end of 2027 for any proposal.

Does the Default Value for Aluminium Capture Any Indirect Cost?

No. The aluminium rows in Annex I to Implementing Regulation (EU) 2025/2621, as replaced by Implementing Regulation (EU) 2026/1740, print "N/A" in the indirect emissions column, so the total default value equals the direct value. China's default for unwrought aluminium (CN 7601) is 3.000 tCO₂e per tonne, direct emissions only, and it contains no electricity emissions. Indirect emissions are not a billable item for aluminium under the current regulation. For a full breakdown of how default values are set and what the mark-up schedule means for your cost planning, see CBAM default values.

How Does Electricity Grid Intensity Affect CBAM Competitiveness for Aluminium Exporters?

Grid intensity shapes competitive outcomes in two directions simultaneously. Exporters on low-carbon grids, such as Norwegian and Icelandic producers using hydropower, face negligible electricity-related (indirect) emissions and benefit from Annex III CBAM exemptions. Their products arrive in the EU with no CBAM cost. Exporters on coal-heavy grids, such as those in China and India, face a direct emissions charge but are shielded from the far larger indirect cost.

This shielding narrows the competitive gap between clean and high-carbon producers more than a full-scope CBAM would. Exporters in the UAE and Bahrain, operating on natural gas grids with emission intensities of approximately 0.5–0.6 tCO₂/MWh, occupy a middle position. Their indirect costs are real but lower than coal-grid competitors. For exporters assessing their long-term position, read the analysis on CBAM impact on aluminium exporters.

Are Perfluorocarbons a Larger Cost Driver Than CO₂ for Some Producers?

PFC emissions can exceed CO₂ emissions on a CO₂e basis for older smelters operating with poor anode effect management. CF₄ carries a GWP of 6,630, meaning even small absolute volumes generate large CO₂e figures. A smelter emitting 0.1 kg CF₄ per tonne of aluminium adds 0.663 tCO₂e per tonne to the CBAM declaration, equivalent to 44% of the base CO₂ direct emission factor of 1.5 tCO₂/t. Modern smelters in Scandinavia and Western Europe have reduced anode effects to near zero. The difference between best-practice and worst-practice PFC management is therefore a material cost differentiator in verified CBAM submissions. For more detail on how PFCs interact with the CBAM reporting obligation, see the article on perfluorocarbons and CBAM.

What Is the Practical Compliance Checklist for Aluminium Importers?

The compliance steps for an EU importer of aluminium goods in the definitive phase fall into three phases. The March 31, 2026 application deadline for provisional importing has passed, so an importer that has not yet applied needs the authorization before importing above the 50-tonne threshold.

The checklist for aluminium importers in 2026 is organized by phase below.

  • Authorization phase: Submit the authorized declarant application to the competent national authority through the CBAM Registry, with the declaration of honour covering the five years preceding the application.
  • Data collection phase (full year 2026): Collect verified direct emission reports from each non-EU supplier installation; request PFC reporting separately if supplier uses older reduction technology.
  • Declaration phase (by September 30, 2027): File the first annual CBAM declaration via the EU CBAM registry, surrendering certificates equal to the embedded direct emissions minus the free allocation adjustment of Article 31 and any Article 9 carbon price reduction.

EU importers sourcing from multiple origins should model the default value cost now, because the 2027 mark-up rises from +10% to +20% above the calculated default. Importers with actual verified data below the default have a growing financial incentive to use actual values from 2027 onward. For a complete compliance workflow specific to aluminium importing businesses, see CBAM compliance for aluminium importers.


Data sources: Regulation (EU) 2023/956 · Regulation (EU) 2025/2083 (Omnibus) · IR 2025/2621 · EU ETS data via EEX. Not legal advice.